On this page
- Who founded Polson, and where does the name come from?
- When did Polson start: 1888 or 1900?
- How did a coffee business end up making butter?
- How did Polson sell butter to Indian homes?
- What did Polson butter taste like?
- What was the Bombay Milk Scheme, and why did Kaira's farmers turn on P…
- How did Amul push Polson out of the market?
- What happened to Polson butter, and can you still buy it?
- Frequently asked questions
Polson butter was India's first big commercial butter brand, built by a Parsi businessman from Bombay, Pestonji Edulji Dalal. He began by roasting and grinding coffee, then turned to butter when he heard the army was short of it. He set up a dairy in Kaira (now Kheda) in Gujarat, salted his butter heavily so it would keep, and sold it to better-off homes with coupons, children's adverts and a girl in a striped dress. ThePrint says Polson dominated the Indian butter trade by the 1930s. Its hold on Kaira's milk then set off the farmers' revolt that produced Amul, and Amul pushed it out of shops from the late 1960s.
શહેરેવર રોજ
Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.
Who founded Polson, and where does the name come from?
Polson was started by Pestonji Edulji Dalal, a Parsi of Bombay. You'll see his first name spelt Pestonji, Pestunji and Pestonjee in different reports. The brand name came from his own nickname. Both ThePrint and The Better India say he was known as Polly, and ThePrint says the nickname was given a British twist to make Polson. We have not found reliable dates for his birth or death, so we leave them out.
For the wider story of Parsi entrepreneurs in Bombay, see our piece on Parsi business history.
When did Polson start: 1888 or 1900?
The sources disagree. The Better India dates his first venture, a small Bombay shop that roasted and ground coffee, to 1888, when he was 13. Slurrp also gives 1888 and says he ground the beans on a hand-turned machine. ThePrint's 2019 brand history instead says Polson was founded in 1900. Both years describe a coffee business, not butter.
Citing Ruth Heredia's book The Amul India Story, The Better India says Dalal borrowed Rs 100 from his sister to start and paid Rs 8 a month in rent. Slurrp also mentions the Rs 100 loan. The Better India adds that he enlarged the shop in 1905 and 1907 and began selling a chicory mix he named Polson's French Coffee.
How did a coffee business end up making butter?
The turn came from a customer. ThePrint says a customer complained that the armed forces could not get enough butter, and The Better India identifies that customer as someone from the Supply Corps. Dalal saw an opening and set up a dairy in the Kaira district of Gujarat.
The year that dairy began is not settled. The Better India gives no year for the move into butter, saying only that the brand was well established by 1910. A 2023 ThePrint opinion piece by TR Vivek says Pestonjee Edulji built his butter factory in Kaira in 1926. The Better India also says a modern, highly automated Polson dairy was running at Anand by 1930.
War kept the plant busy. According to Heredia, as quoted by The Better India, Polson's success was built on three wars, the Boer War and the two World Wars, when it supplied butter to British Indian and American forces. The same article says output had reached about 3 million pounds of butter a year by 1945.
How did Polson sell butter to Indian homes?
Factory butter was a hard sell at first. ThePrint points out that most Indian households still churned their own, very few had a refrigerator, and shop butter was a costly status item bought mainly by wealthy families and Anglo-Indians. Polson had to persuade people to pay for something they had always made at home.
It did that with marketing more than flavour. ThePrint and The Better India both describe gift coupons packed with the butter that could be saved up for toasters or mixers. ThePrint says it was sold as butter children loved, under the line "Guard their health and give them the best". The Better India describes the face of the brand: a blonde girl in a blue-and-white striped dress, shown spreading butter on toast.
It worked. ThePrint says Polson dominated India's butter business by the 1930s, and quotes advertising expert Navroze Dhondy saying the name had become a generic word for butter by the 1950s and 1960s. Kurush Dalal, writing in Live History India, calls it the country's number one butter brand of its day. Brand consultant Harish Bijoor told ThePrint that people "trusted and loved it".
What did Polson butter taste like?
Polson butter was salty and slightly sour. Slurrp says the company added plenty of salt to preserve it, which mattered when few homes had a fridge. Kurush Dalal describes it as fermented, salted butter, and adds that it was made from cow's milk, which gives a naturally yellower colour than buffalo milk. ThePrint calls the taste salty but unremarkable.
That flavour became the standard Indians expected. It would later trip up Polson's biggest rival.
What was the Bombay Milk Scheme, and why did Kaira's farmers turn on Polson?
In 1945 the Bombay government started the Bombay Milk Scheme, carrying milk from Kaira to the city every day. The Better India puts the distance at about 400 km; TR Vivek gives 330 km. ThePrint's opinion piece and The Better India both say Polson held the monopoly on that supply. The farmers who produced the milk saw little of the money. According to TR Vivek, only a fraction of the consumer price reached them, Polson and its contractors pocketed most of the money, and payments were cut over complaints of flies in the milk or low fat content.
A farmers' delegation took its case to Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, who backed a cooperative so that farmers could control their milk themselves. TR Vivek writes that Patel asked Morarji Desai to coordinate the effort and that Desai chose Tribhuvandas Patel to head the cooperative. Slurrp also names Tribhuvandas Patel as its founder. Farmers then refused to sell to Polson and, by Vivek's account, struck for 15 days, pouring milk away rather than supplying it. The Kaira District Cooperative Milk Producers' Union was formed in December 1946. ThePrint's opinion piece calls it the mother of Amul, and Khushwant Singh, writing in Outlook, says the union became better known by its butter, Amul.
How did Amul push Polson out of the market?
Not at first. Kurush Dalal writes that the first Amul butter, launched in 1955, flopped. It was unsalted and made from fresh buffalo-milk cream, so it looked pale and tasted flat to buyers raised on Polson. Verghese Kurien, who had joined the Kaira cooperative, changed the recipe to match: he added salt, a flavouring compound that occurs naturally in fermented cream, and colouring to make it yellow. Slurrp tells the same story of salting and colouring to copy the older taste.
Amul then won on scale and branding. ThePrint dates Polson's decline to Amul's arrival in the market in the late 1960s, and Khushwant Singh's Outlook piece says the cooperative's butter "knocked Polson from the market". The Better India says the Amul girl, created in the 1960s by Sylvester da Cunha and Eugene Fernandez, was a reply to Polson's butter girl. Harish Bijoor's verdict, given to ThePrint, is blunt: "Polson thought small."
Another Bombay Parsi dairy name, Parsi Dairy Farm, took a different path and is still trading more than a century later.
What happened to Polson butter, and can you still buy it?
No, you can't buy Polson butter today. The Better India reports that by the 1970s Dalal's children had moved away from the business, the company was bought over, and it was turned towards tanning and leather goods. We have found only that one account of the leather years.
There was a short revival. The Better India says Polson butter turned up again around 2012 and 2013 at Farm Products in Colaba, Mumbai, which the article describes as the city's oldest cold storage. It was reportedly relaunched by a relative of Dalal, though the rest of the family was unhappy with the decision, and The Better India says it vanished again and has not resurfaced.
Frequently asked questions
Who founded Polson butter?
Polson was founded by Pestonji Edulji Dalal, a Parsi businessman from Bombay. He started with a coffee roasting and grinding business and moved into butter after learning the army was short of it. The brand name Polson comes from his nickname, Polly, which ThePrint says was given an English-sounding twist.
Is Polson butter still available in India?
No. Polson butter is not sold in India today. The Better India reports that the company was sold by the 1970s and moved into tanning and leather. A brief revival around 2012 and 2013, sold at Farm Products in Colaba, Mumbai, did not last, and we found no later report of it on sale.
What is the difference between Polson and Amul butter?
Polson was a private company's butter, made from cow's milk, salted and slightly fermented in taste. Amul came from the Kaira farmers' cooperative formed in 1946 and used buffalo milk. Its first unsalted version in 1955 failed, so Verghese Kurien added salt, flavour and colour to match Polson's taste.
Who was the Polson butter girl?
The Polson butter girl was the brand's advertising mascot: a blonde girl in a blue-and-white striped dress, shown buttering toast. The Better India says the Amul girl, created in the 1960s by Sylvester da Cunha and Eugene Fernandez, was designed as a response to her. The real name of any model is not recorded in our sources.
Why did Polson butter decline?
Polson lost its milk base and then its market. Kaira's farmers, unhappy with Polson's prices under the 1945 Bombay Milk Scheme, formed their own cooperative in 1946, which became Amul. From the late 1960s Amul's scale and branding overtook Polson, and by the 1970s the company had been sold.
PalV's Kasti


