Skip to content

Food

Parsi bhakras and gharis: what they are and when Parsis make them

The fried tea-time cake and the date-filled pastry, from toddy leaven to malido and RTI's counter.

Title card: Parsi bhakras and gharis – The fried tea-time cake and the date-filled pastry, and when Parsi families make them
On this page
  1. What is a Parsi bhakra?
  2. Is bhakra made with toddy?
  3. What is a ghari, and what is khajoor ni ghari?
  4. When do Parsis make bhakras and gharis?
  5. Where can you buy bhakras and gharis?
  6. Frequently asked questions

A Parsi bhakra is a small, lightly sweet cake cut from a stiff dough of flour, semolina, sugar and ghee or butter, then deep-fried until it puffs and turns golden. Cardamom and nutmeg flavour it in the recipes we read, and some cooks add caraway. A ghari is a different thing: a filled pastry, where a round of dough is closed over dates and nuts (khajoor ni ghari) or caramelised coconut and fried in ghee. Both belong to the Parsi tea table. In the sources we read, neither is tied to a fixed festival. Bhakras were made in big batches and kept for days, and they also turn up inside malido, where fried bhakras are crushed to make its base.

TodayMon 16 Nov

શહેરેવર રોજ

Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What is a Parsi bhakra?

Every cook we read describes the same idea a little differently. FEZANA's 2012 community cookbook Eat, Live, Pray titles its recipe "Bhakra, Parsi donut". Rita Jamshed Kapadia of ParsiCuisine.com calls bhakhras fried cakes to have with tea or coffee. Perzen Patel, who writes as the Bawi Bride, puts it best: a dense doughnut without the toppings. And Niloufer Mavalvala, in The Cook's Cook, calls it a deep-fried semolina and saffron treat (one of her articles spells it bhokra).

So there's no hole in the middle and no glaze. The dough is rolled out, cut into small rounds and fried.

What goes into bhakras?

The published recipes we read share a base of semolina (ravo), wheat flour, sugar, ghee or butter and eggs, with yoghurt or toddy to leaven the dough. Quantities, nuts and resting times vary a lot from one family recipe to the next.

Kapadia's version mixes whole wheat and plain flour with semolina, ghee, one egg and a cardamom-and-nutmeg mix, with caraway optional. She is firm that it must be real caraway and not shahi jeera, because the taste isn't the same. She rolls the dough about a quarter-inch thick, cuts inch-and-a-half rounds, and warns that bhakras puff up in the oil, so test its heat before the first batch goes in.

Is bhakra made with toddy?

It can be. Toddy (tari, fermented palm sap) went into bhakras in the older kitchens our sources describe, and you'll still find it in some. In Parsi Times, Dara Khodaiji recalls his grandmother's kitchen in the 1950s: if a relative from the country smuggled in a couple of bottles of palm toddy, part of it was used for bhakhras, sadhnas or kumas. Kapadia writes that the bhakhras she buys in Udvada are made with taari. Upper Crust magazine has also printed a "bhakra with tari" recipe among dishes cooked in Udvada, Devka, Dahanu and Gholvad.

The home recipes we read lean on yoghurt instead. Kapadia gives a choice of two tablespoons of yoghurt or 125 ml of toddy mixed with sugar and warm water, and says beer can stand in for toddy. The FEZANA and Bawi Bride recipes use yoghurt alone. A toddy bhakra is the older taste. A yoghurt bhakra is what most of us can actually make at home.

What is a ghari, and what is khajoor ni ghari?

A ghari (also written gharry or gharri) is a small filled pastry. The best known is khajoor ni ghari, also spelt khajur ni ghari, which Mavalvala describes as dates and almonds in a semolina crust. Khodaiji remembers gharries from his grandmother's tea table that were stuffed either with caramelised coconut or with dates and plenty of almonds and raisins.

How is khajoor ni ghari made?

Mavalvala's method in the FEZANA cookbook gives a clear picture of the work. Chopped dates are cooked soft in smen or ghee, with rosewater and a pinch of salt. The pastry is flour, semolina, baking powder, salt and smen. It's rolled into a large circle, brushed with a paste of smen and flour, twisted into a long roll and chilled for half an hour. Then it's cut into two-inch pieces, each one shaped into a cup, filled with dates, closed over the top, pressed into a disc and shallow-fried in ghee on both sides until golden.

That brushed-and-rolled dough is what gives the crust its layers. A note beside the recipe in the same cookbook says khajoor ni ghari and dar ni pori are the closest things Parsis have to early baklava, which was made with dough filled with dates and nuts rather than with filo.

When do Parsis make bhakras and gharis?

Mostly at tea-time. Mavalvala lists bhakra alongside batasa, nankhatai and kumas as the things to dunk in a strong cup of tea, and Khodaiji names bhakhras and gharries among his grandmother's tea-time snacks. If you want the rest of that table, our guide to Parsi choi covers the tea itself.

Bhakras keep well. Khodaiji writes that they were made in large quantities and stored to be served over several days, and Kapadia keeps hers in an airtight glass jar. Beyond that, we found no source that ties bhakras or gharis to a particular festival or roj. The one firm link to a timetable was toddy: in Khodaiji's telling, bhakras got made when the tari arrived.

Bhakras and malido

Bhakras also have a working role. The traditional malido recipe in the FEZANA cookbook starts by frying plain bhakras of semolina, wholemeal flour and oats, then crushing them with a rolling pin. Those crumbs are stirred into sugar syrup and cooked with eggs and dry fruit to make the malido. The same page notes that for many Parsis malido matters at a jashan, as one of the offerings placed on the ritual cloth, and Kapadia's ParsiCuisine.com also lists malido in trays among the things used at a jashan. Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Where can you buy bhakras and gharis?

In Mumbai, the Ratan Tata Institute (RTI), set up in 1928 by Lady Navajbai Tata, is the name that comes up. The Tata group's newsroom describes the RTI kitchen as known for Parsi sweets including dar ni pori and khajur ni ghari, and a 2023 Local Samosa piece lists bhakra among the must-tries at RTI's outlets, which it counted at ten across the city. Menus change, so check before you go.

Outside Mumbai, Kapadia writes that she buys fresh bhakhras from Parsi Industrial in Ahmedabad and, in Udvada, from a small shop opposite the Atash Behram.

Gharis are harder to find. In a 2017 interview with Man's World India, Perzen Patel put dar ni poris and khajur ni gharis among dishes she felt would soon be lost to the younger generation. For the wider family of festive mithai, see our guide to Parsi sweets.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Parsi bhakra?

A Parsi bhakra (also bhakhra or bhokra) is a small deep-fried cake made from semolina, wheat flour, sugar, ghee or butter and usually eggs, spiced with cardamom and nutmeg. It has no hole and no topping. FEZANA's cookbook calls it the Parsi doughnut, and families eat it with tea, often from a big batch stored for days.

Is bhakra made with toddy?

It can be. Toddy (tari) went into bhakras in older Parsi kitchens, and Rita Kapadia says the bhakhras she buys in Udvada still use it. The home recipes we read lean on yoghurt instead. Kapadia's own recipe lets you pick yoghurt or toddy mixed with sugar and warm water, and she says beer can replace the toddy.

What is khajur ni ghari?

Khajur ni ghari (or khajoor ni ghari) is a Parsi pastry of soft cooked dates, often with almonds, sealed inside a flour-and-semolina crust and fried in ghee. Niloufer Mavalvala's version flavours the dates with rosewater and layers the dough with a smen-and-flour paste. Dara Khodaiji also remembers gharis filled with caramelised coconut.

Where can I buy bhakras in Mumbai?

The Ratan Tata Institute (RTI) is the name that comes up in Mumbai. A 2023 Local Samosa report listed bhakra among the must-tries at RTI's outlets, and the Tata group says RTI's kitchen is known for khajur ni ghari. Stock and menus change, so call ahead. Rita Kapadia also buys them in Udvada and Ahmedabad.

Are bhakras eaten on any special day?

We found no source tying bhakras to a fixed festival. They're an everyday tea-time snack, made in large batches and stored for days. Their ceremonial link is indirect: FEZANA's traditional malido recipe begins with fried bhakras crushed into crumbs, and the same cookbook says that for many Parsis malido is a jashan offering.

Share this article

Facebook