Skip to content

Food

Dhansak in Pakistan: How Karachi's Parsis Cook and Eat It

Sunday lunches, compound Gahambars and a home kitchen that delivers: dhansak as Karachi's Parsis keep it.

Title card: Dhansak in Pakistan – How Karachi's Parsis cook and eat dhansak: Sunday lunch, Gahambars and brown rice
On this page
  1. What does dhansak look like on a Karachi Parsi table?
  2. Is dhansak still a Sunday lunch for Parsis in Pakistan?
  3. How is dhansak cooked in a Karachi kitchen?
  4. When do Parsis in Pakistan serve dhansak, and when do they not?
  5. Where can you eat Parsi dhansak in Pakistan today?
  6. How many Parsis are left in Pakistan to keep cooking it?
  7. Frequently asked questions

Parsis in Pakistan, most of whom now live in Karachi, cook dhansak from lentils and vegetables boiled soft and blended, then simmered with meat and spices, and they eat it with brown rice cooked with caramelised sugar and onion. That is how the recipes and reports published in Karachi describe it. Writers in Dawn describe it as a Sunday lunch dish at home, and The Express Tribune lists it on the menu at Karachi Gahambar feasts. For the dish itself, start with our guide to Dhansak.

TodayMon 16 Nov

શહેરેવર રોજ

Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What does dhansak look like on a Karachi Parsi table?

Writing in Dawn, Bisma Tirmizi recalled going to interview the columnist Ardeshir Cowasjee at his Bath Island bungalow for a 1997 supplement and finding him eating dhansak on caramelised brown rice. Nearly three decades later, Arab News described the dish in Gulnar Cowasjee's Karachi kitchen in almost the same words: lentils, meat and spices cooked slowly and eaten with caramelised brown rice.

In a 2016 Express Tribune feature the dish appears as Dhansak Chawal. Gulnar Cowasjee, speaking to Geo News, spelt it Dhansag and compared it to daal chawal with vegetables added, so that rice, pulses and vegetables arrive in one helping.

Is dhansak still a Sunday lunch for Parsis in Pakistan?

Yes, in the homes that still cook it. A 2011 Dawn magazine piece on Parsi food called dhansak a Sunday afternoon staple, and Tirmizi wrote in 2014 that it is traditionally cooked for Sunday lunch and is heavy enough to earn an afternoon nap. Niloufer Mavalvala, who was born in Karachi and now lives in Canada, says the same in her cookbook The Art of Parsi Cooking: dhansak is kept for a treat, and more traditionally for Sunday lunch.

The Sunday table has shrunk, though. Gulnar Cowasjee told Arab News in 2025 that her family once sat 25 to 28 people at a meal and now does not fill a table of two.

How is dhansak cooked in a Karachi kitchen?

The most detailed Karachi recipe we found is the one Tirmizi published in Dawn in 2014, credited to her friend Teenaz Javat, whom she calls a Mumbaiite married to a Karachiite. In outline, without its quantities:

  • Four dals go in: masoor, moong, toor and chana, soaked and then boiled.
  • Aubergine, red pumpkin, potato, carrot and spinach cook with the dals, and the whole pot is blended smooth.
  • In a separate pan, ginger-garlic paste, onion, tomato, green chillies and spices (including dhansak garam masala and fenugreek seeds) are fried, the mutton is added, and then the blended dal goes in. Our page on Dhansak masala explains that spice blend.
  • For the rice, sliced onion, brown sugar and whole spices (cardamom, cloves, peppercorns, bay leaf) are browned until the sugar caramelises, and the rice is then cooked in stock.
  • It is finished with lemon, coriander and caramelised onion, with kachumber (chopped onion, tomato and cucumber) on the side.

Do not expect one fixed Karachi version. The 2011 Dawn piece said plainly that a dhansak recipe changes from household to household, and Gulnar Cowasjee told Arab News she learnt by watching her grandmother.

When do Parsis in Pakistan serve dhansak, and when do they not?

Sunday lunch is the everyday answer. The Gahambar is the communal one. Dilaira Dubash wrote in The Express Tribune in 2012 that each Parsi residential compound in Karachi holds its own Gahambar, invites the other compounds, and serves dhansak chawal alongside papeta ma gosht. Women once cooked these feasts themselves, she noted, but caterers now do it, and butter paper on cardboard has replaced banana leaves. Dawn's 2011 article gave the same Gahambar order for Pakistan and much of India: chutneys and pickles, papeta ma gosht, often dhansak, then Parsi custard.

Dhansak is also linked with mourning: Tirmizi's Dawn article quotes Charmaine O'Brien's food guide to India saying it is customarily served four days after a death, and Gulnar Cowasjee told Geo News that in Karachi's community dhansag is served at funerals. Why it is kept off happy occasions is a question for our separate page on dhansak customs.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Where can you eat Parsi dhansak in Pakistan today?

The reports we found name only a few places, and none is a full-time Parsi restaurant.

Home kitchens that deliver

Gulnar Cowasjee runs Ghar Se, a home-based delivery kitchen in Karachi that she started during the COVID-19 pandemic. Dhansak is among the dishes she cooks. She told Geo News that most of her customers are Muslims, with orders arriving every week.

Club and hotel lunches

In 2016 The Express Tribune reported that the Karachi Parsi Institute's Sunday lunch was popular, though the report did not list the menu. In the same year Byram Avari, chairman of the Avari Group, told Dawn that the group's hotels served dhansak once a week. He added that a full-time Parsi restaurant could not be justified. Both reports are ten years old, so check with the venue before you go. For a Mumbai club lunch, see our page on Ripon Club dhansak.

A little history

Tirmizi wrote that Parsi migrants from Iran ran small corner tea shops in Karachi and Bombay, selling soda water, biscuits, tea, omelettes and dhansak. We found that claim in her article only.

How many Parsis are left in Pakistan to keep cooking it?

Very few. The Express Tribune put the number at around 5,000 at independence in 1947. Arab News cites the 2023 national census count of 2,348 Parsis in Pakistan, and The Express Tribune gave the same figure in 2026. An AFP report in March 2025, quoting community leaders, put the number nearer 900 in Karachi and a few dozen more elsewhere. The census and the community estimate do not agree. The wider story is on our page on the Parsis of Pakistan, and the rest of the table is in our guide to Parsi food.

Frequently asked questions

Is Pakistani Parsi dhansak different from Indian Parsi dhansak?

The sources we read do not describe a separate Pakistani style. The Karachi recipe in Dawn came from Teenaz Javat, a Mumbaiite married to a Karachiite, and uses several dals, vegetables, mutton and caramelised brown rice. Dawn's 2011 food page stressed that a dhansak recipe changes from household to household, so expect variation between families.

What do Karachi Parsis eat with dhansak?

Karachi Parsis eat dhansak with brown rice cooked with caramelised sugar, onion and whole spices. Teenaz Javat's recipe in Dawn finishes the dal with lemon, coriander and caramelised onion and serves kachumber, a salad of chopped onion, tomato and cucumber, on the side. Express Tribune writers call the full plate dhansak chawal.

Is dhansak served at Gahambars in Karachi?

Yes, according to The Express Tribune. Its 2012 report said each Karachi Parsi compound holds its own Gahambar and serves dhansak chawal with papeta ma gosht. Dawn described the same Gahambar menu for Pakistan in 2011. Practice varies between families and Agiaries, so ask your own priest about any specific feast.

Is dhansak still a Sunday lunch dish in Karachi?

In the homes that still cook it, yes. Dawn called dhansak a Sunday afternoon staple in 2011, and Bisma Tirmizi wrote in Dawn in 2014 that it is traditionally cooked for Sunday lunch. Karachi-born author Niloufer Mavalvala says in her cookbook that it is kept for a treat and, more traditionally, for Sunday lunch.

Can you order Parsi dhansak in Karachi?

Yes. Arab News and Geo News have both reported on Ghar Se, a home delivery kitchen run by Gulnar Cowasjee that cooks dhansak and other Parsi dishes. The Express Tribune reported a popular Sunday lunch at the Karachi Parsi Institute in 2016. Confirm current days and menus directly, as these reports are dated.

Share this article

Facebook