Skip to content

Food

What Is Dhansak? The Parsi Dish Explained, and What It Is Not

Lentils, meat and caramelised rice: what dhansak is, where the name comes from, and what it is not.

Title card: What is dhansak? – The Parsi dal of lentils, meat and caramelised rice, and what it is not
On this page
  1. What is dhansak, exactly?
  2. What does the word dhansak (dhan-sak) mean?
  3. What makes dhansak a Parsi dish?
  4. What is dhansak not?
  5. Is dhansak a Parsi Sunday lunch?
  6. Frequently asked questions

Dhansak is one of the best-known Parsi dishes: a thick, spiced dal of several lentils and vegetables, cooked with meat (mutton or goat by tradition, though chicken is common too) and ladled over caramelised "brown" rice, with a sharp kachumbar of onion, tomato and cucumber on the side. What makes it Parsi is where it was made. Writers trace it to the Persian stew khoresh, but the dish Parsis cook today was built in Gujarat and later Bombay from Indian pulses, vegetables and spices. And there are things it is not. It is not usually wedding food, because of its link with mourning. It is not the pineapple-studded "dhansak curry" of UK curry houses. And it is not one fixed recipe.

TodayMon 16 Nov

અદીબેહેસત રોજ

Ardibehesht Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What is dhansak, exactly?

Dhansak is a one-plate meal with three parts that are meant to be eaten together. The first is the dal itself, which Perzen Patel, the Parsi cook behind Bawi Bride Kitchen, describes plainly as a spicy dahl made with meat and a few vegetables. The second is the rice. The third is the set of sides: kachumbar, lemon wedges and, often, small kebabs.

Food writer Sona Bahadur remembers her first dhansak at a Parsi family's Sunday lunch in Mumbai, in the mid-1990s, coming with prawn kebabs and kachumbar. Chef Anahita Dhondy, writing in the Deccan Chronicle, names the same two companions.

What goes into dhansak dal?

Dhansak dal is usually a blend rather than a single lentil. Toor is in Outlook Traveller's list, in Patel's recipe and in Bahadur's account, with chana, masoor or moong added. Patel's own recipe uses toor, moong and masoor in a two-to-one-to-one ratio, while food photographer Yasmin Khambatta, quoted by Bahadur, uses all four.

Vegetables go in with the lentils. Pumpkin, brinjal, tomato and fresh methi (fenugreek) leaves appear in Outlook Traveller's account, in Bahadur's and in Patel's recipe. Once soft, the whole pot is mashed, blended or strained into a thick, smooth dal and the cooked meat goes back in. Bahadur credits the pumpkin and onions with sweetness and the methi with a bitter edge.

Patel calls dhansak masala an all-in-one spice blend, with cumin, coriander, cinnamon and a little chilli among its flavours. Our guide to Dhansak masala covers what goes into it and how to grind it at home. For a full step-by-step mutton version, see our Dhansak recipe, and for the poultry version, our Chicken dhansak.

Is dhansak brown rice really brown rice?

No. The "brown rice" served under dhansak is white rice that takes its colour from caramelised jaggery or sugar. Patel says so directly (her recipe uses basmati), and Bahadur describes the rice at her first dhansak lunch as caramelised white rice. Outlook Traveller calls it vugharela chawal.

What does the word dhansak (dhan-sak) mean?

The four sources we read agree that the second half, sak or shaak, means vegetables. The first half is where they part ways, and we would rather show you the disagreement than pick one.

  • Dhan as lentils: Homegrown's history of the dish reads the name as dhan (lentils) plus shaak (vegetables).
  • Dhan as grain or rice: Outlook Traveller links the name to Gujarati words for grain or rice and for vegetables.
  • Dhan as wealth: Dawn, citing Pat Chapman's book, gives dhan as "wealthy" in Gujarati, and adds that dhaan, said slightly differently, is the rice served with it. Chef Anahita Dhondy reads it as gold or wealth too.

None of these sources points to an old written record that settles it, so treat each explanation as one reading among several.

What makes dhansak a Parsi dish?

Dhansak is Parsi because the Parsis made it in India from what they brought and what they found. Dawn, the Deccan Chronicle and Homegrown all trace it to khoresh, the Persian stew. Dawn and Anahita Dhondy both describe an early form of meat with spinach and plums over rice, and Homegrown calls dhansak a cross between Persian and Gujarati cooking. Once the Zoroastrian migrants from Persia had settled in Gujarat (Bahadur and Saveur both place the arrival in the eighth century), local pulses, vegetables and spices took over.

The Indian food historian K.T. Achaya, as quoted by Bahadur, suggested that pulses took the place of the rajma beans and spinach of the Iranian dish. That swap is the heart of it. A Persian meat stew became an Indian lentil dish.

Nobody can date the first dhansak. Outlook Traveller and Homegrown both say its early history rests on oral tradition and family recipes more than on written records. How the dish spread and changed after that is told in our Dhansak history, and the Karachi side of the story in Dhansak in Pakistan.

What is dhansak not?

It is not usually wedding or Navjote food

Outlook Traveller, Homegrown and Dawn (citing the food writer Charmaine O'Brien) all say dhansak is kept away from weddings and other happy occasions because it is the meal served on the fourth day after a death. Perzen Patel calls the rule "a bit of a myth", since Parsis eat dhansak on birthdays and new years too. Her family's workaround is to cook the meat into a mutton pulao and serve the dhansak-style dal alongside. In her words, if the meat is not cooked with the dal, it is not dhansak but masala ni dar. Outlook Traveller names pulao-dar in the same way, as the dish that gives happy occasions meat and rice without the mourning association.

What happens in the days after a death, and when dhansak is and is not served, is covered in our Dhansak customs guide.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

It is not the British curry-house dhansak

The British met dhansak in India. Dawn, drawing on the historian Lizzie Collingham's book Curry, and Homegrown both say the British came to know it through Parsi households and butlers, and it ended up on British Indian restaurant menus. The restaurant version changed along the way. Patel points out that UK curry houses make it with what Parsis would call bizarre additions such as pineapple, pomegranate and tamarind, and that the British call it a curry when it really belongs with the dals.

It is not one fixed recipe

Parsi cooks disagree on the details. In Bahadur's reporting, food entrepreneur Mahrukh Mogrelia wants the sweetness to come from the vegetables rather than sugar or jaggery, chef Jeroo Shroff objects to masoor standing in for toor, and families split between mutton and chicken. Outlook Traveller puts it simply: there is no single recipe. A dhansak that differs from your grandmother's is not wrong. It is someone else's grandmother's.

Is dhansak a Parsi Sunday lunch?

Yes. Dawn, Homegrown, Outlook Traveller and Niloufer Mavalvala's cookbook The Art of Parsi Cooking all tie it to Sunday lunch, and Dawn and Mavalvala both follow the meal with a nap. Why the dish carries so much feeling for the community is the subject of Why Parsis love dhansak.

Two more pieces sit in this series. The columnist Busybee wrote about the dish, and Busybee on dhansak looks at what he said. The Ripon Club's place in the dhansak story is told in Ripon Club dhansak. If you are new to the wider cuisine, our overview of Parsi food is the place to start.

Frequently asked questions

What is dhansak made of?

Dhansak is made of a blend of lentils, usually toor with some chana, masoor or moong, cooked with vegetables such as pumpkin, brinjal, tomato and methi leaves. The dal is blended smooth, spiced with dhansak masala and cooked with mutton or chicken. It is served over caramelised brown rice with kachumbar, lemon and often small kebabs.

What does dhansak mean?

Sak or shaak means vegetables, and the sources agree on that. Dhan is read three ways: as lentils (Homegrown), as grain or rice (Outlook Traveller) and as wealth (Dawn, citing Pat Chapman, and chef Anahita Dhondy). None of them cites an old written record that settles it, so each is one reading among several.

Is dhansak Persian or Indian?

Dhansak is an Indian Parsi dish with Persian roots. Writers in Dawn, the Deccan Chronicle and Homegrown trace it to khoresh, a Persian stew, and Dawn and the Deccan Chronicle describe meat with spinach and plums. In Gujarat the Parsis rebuilt it with Indian pulses, vegetables and spices, so today's lentil-heavy dish took its shape in India.

Can dhansak be vegetarian?

Yes. Vegetable dhansak keeps the blended lentil dal and the caramelised brown rice but is made without meat, so it suits vegetarian guests. Outlook Traveller notes that vegetarian versions exist alongside the mutton and chicken ones, and Saveur describes a veg dhansak of brown rice with dal and vegetables such as eggplant and pumpkin.

Is lamb dhansak the same as Parsi mutton dhansak?

Close, but not always. Mutton or goat is the traditional Parsi meat, and Perzen Patel's recipe lists lamb as an option for the same dal. The bigger difference is usually the recipe. UK curry-house versions can include pineapple, pomegranate and tamarind, which Patel says Parsis would find bizarre. The Parsi dish is a thick, spiced lentil dal.

Share this article

Facebook