Skip to content

Food

Busybee on Dhansak: What Behram Contractor Wrote About the Parsi Dish

Bombay's Busybee defined dhansak in four lines, and he ruled out chicken entirely.

Title card: Busybee on dhansak – Rice, masala dal, mutton on the bone cooked in the dal, and never chicken
On this page
  1. Who was Busybee?
  2. What exactly did Busybee say dhansak is?
  3. Why did Busybee call chicken dhansak a sacrilege?
  4. Where did Busybee eat dhanshak in Bombay?
  5. Where can you read Busybee's food writing today?
  6. Frequently asked questions

Busybee, the pen name of the Bombay columnist Behram Contractor, gave Parsi dhansak a definition that left no room for argument. Writing on the occasion of the Parsi New Year, he said dhansak is rice and masala dal, with the meat cooked in the dal. The meat, he insisted, is always mutton: large pieces, on the bone, with the marrow still inside. And it is never chicken. "Chicken Dhansak is a sacrilege," he wrote. Upper Crust, the food guide The Tribune says he published with his wife Farzana, reprints the passage among what it calls his classic food quotes. His columns also kept track of where he ate it. In a 1995 piece he remembered an Irani restaurant that served dhanshak every Wednesday.

TodayMon 16 Nov

અદીબેહેસત રોજ

Ardibehesht Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

Who was Busybee?

Behram Contractor wrote a daily column called Round and About under the name Busybee. Upper Crust says the column ran for 36 years, and a Penguin collection of his pieces was titled Busybee, The Best of Thirty-Six Years. He worked at the Free Press Journal, The Times of India and Mid-Day, and in 1985 he started his own evening paper, The Afternoon Despatch & Courier. He died in Mumbai on 9 April 2001.

Food was a constant in his writing. The Tribune's report of his death noted that he wrote about cricket and food. Upper Crust goes further and calls him the country's first food writer. The writer Dom Moraes, in a piece Scroll republished in 2019, said Contractor wrote particularly well about his own community, "its customs, its conversation, and its food", and that he was an excellent food writer because "he makes you want to eat it". If you want the wider picture he was writing from, our guide to Parsi food covers the rest of the table.

What exactly did Busybee say dhansak is?

The passage is short. Busybee opens with "some thoughts on the Parsi dhansak" for the Parsi New Year, asks what dhansak is, and answers in four plain claims:

  • It is rice and masala dal.
  • The meat is cooked in the dal, not served beside it.
  • The meat is always mutton, cut in large pieces and left on the bone, marrow and all.
  • It is never chicken. In his words, chicken dhansak is a sacrilege.

He gives no recipe and no spice list. What he cared about was the build of the dish: the meat goes into the dal, and the meat is mutton with its bones. For what dhansak is and what it is not in fuller detail, read our main page on Dhansak.

Why did Busybee call chicken dhansak a sacrilege?

He doesn't say, and we won't put reasons in his mouth. The writer Dom Moraes said Busybee's style created "an impression of deadpan comedy". We read the line as one Bombay Parsi's firm preference, stated as a rule.

Not every Parsi cook agrees with him. Perzen Patel, who writes the Beyond Butter Chicken newsletter, lists "lamb, goat, beef or chicken" as the meat in her own dhansak recipe. On the other half of his rule, though, she lands right where Busybee did. She writes that if the meat isn't cooked with the dal, the dish technically isn't dhansak but masala ni dar. Busybee wrote before 2001 and Patel in 2024, and both draw the line at the meat going into the pot.

Where did Busybee eat dhanshak in Bombay?

In this column Busybee spelt it dhanshak. In a piece that, according to Upper Crust, first appeared in the Afternoon Despatch & Courier on 24 April 1995, he wrote about the Stadium, which became his favourite Irani restaurant after the Asiatic across the road closed. The Stadium, he recalled, served Parsi food on a weekly rota:

  • Sundays: curry rice
  • Wednesdays: dhanshak
  • Saturdays: khichri-masoor

By the time he wrote, that rota was gone. The Irani owners had sold or let out the place, and its kitchen, in his words, had become "Muslim-Chinese". The column is a small record of how a weekday dhansak could disappear from a Bombay street when one restaurant changed hands. For how the dish itself came to be, see our page on Dhansak history, and for its place in Parsi family life, Why Parsis love dhansak.

Where can you read Busybee's food writing today?

Upper Crust has put a selection of his food lines online under the title "Busybee Speak", and the dhansak passage is number 18 of them. Its older web archive carries the 1995 Stadium column. In print, The Tribune reviewed the Penguin collection Busybee, The Best of Thirty-Six Years in 2002. The Afternoon Despatch & Courier, the paper he founded, announced its closure on 20 July 2019, Scroll reported.

Frequently asked questions

Who was Busybee, the Bombay columnist?

Busybee was the pen name of Behram Contractor, a Parsi journalist who wrote the daily Round and About column in Bombay. He worked at the Free Press Journal, The Times of India and Mid-Day, founded The Afternoon Despatch & Courier in 1985, and died in Mumbai on 9 April 2001. Food was one of his regular subjects.

What did Busybee say about chicken dhansak?

Busybee wrote that dhansak "is never chicken" and that "Chicken Dhansak is a sacrilege". For him the meat was always mutton, in large pieces on the bone with the marrow intact, cooked inside the masala dal. He gave no reason for the rule. Perzen Patel, a Parsi cook writing today, lists chicken in her own recipe.

How did Busybee define Parsi dhansak?

Busybee defined Parsi dhansak as rice and masala dal with the meat cooked in the dal. He added that the meat is always mutton, cut into large pieces, with the bone and the marrow left in. He wrote the passage on the occasion of the Parsi New Year, and Upper Crust reprints it in its "Busybee Speak" selection.

Is it spelt dhansak or dhanshak?

Both spellings appear in Busybee's own writing. His New Year passage uses "dhansak", while his 1995 column about the Stadium restaurant uses "dhanshak". Either way, he meant the same Parsi dish: rice with masala dal, the meat cooked in the dal.

Which restaurant did Busybee say served dhanshak on Wednesdays?

In a column dated 24 April 1995, Busybee wrote that the Stadium, his favourite Irani restaurant after the Asiatic closed, served dhanshak on Wednesdays. It also served curry rice on Sundays and khichri-masoor on Saturdays. He noted that the Irani owners later sold or let out the place and its kitchen changed.

Share this article

Facebook