On this page
Kolkata's Parsi cheese is topli na paneer, the soft basket cheese served at Parsi wedding feasts, and the most recent published report we found traces it to a single kitchen. In March 2018, India Today profiled Viloo Batliwala, then 73, and described her as the only person in the city making it. The magazine said she had been making it for over 40 years, sold from Ripon Street by appointment, and set fresh batches only on Tuesdays and Fridays. We could not find any report after 2018 that says whether she still makes it or names anyone who has taken it on. Everything below is dated to the source it comes from.
અદીબેહેસત રોજ
Ardibehesht Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.
Who makes topli na paneer in Kolkata?
The name in print is Viloo Batliwala. India Today's 2018 piece, written by Malini Banerjee for the magazine's supplement, began with a problem. Food reaches most homes at the tap of a phone, yet this cheese was hard to get hold of in Kolkata, and her regular customers knew where to go.
The same profile says she once made other Parsi goodies, including bhakras for the Parsi club, and later stopped. "Now I don't quite have the energy to make more," she told the magazine. By 2018 her output was down to two things: topli na paneer and plain cottage cheese.
So the honest answer to "who keeps it going" is one woman, as of 2018. India Today is the only publisher page we could open that names her. We have kept to what that profile reported and have not added anything about her life beyond it.
How does Viloo Batliwala make her basket cheese?
According to India Today, Batliwala learnt the recipe from her mother-in-law. She then spent a good while experimenting until the saltiness tasted right to her. Her method, as the magazine described it in 2018:
- Fresh buffalo milk, bought early in the morning from Pure Milk Emporium.
- The milk is left to set in small cane baskets, the topli that give the cheese its name.
- The cheese is ready by about 10 a.m. the same morning.
- Batches on Tuesdays and Fridays only.
The 2018 prices were Rs 260 for a set of eight pieces, and Rs 290 for her fresh cottage cheese. Treat both figures as history, not a price list.
India Today called it a Parsi take on Italian buffalo mozzarella. Batliwala's own serving advice was plainer: eat it on its own, or on toast with salt and pepper. The magazine found it popular with the city's younger diners, and Sienna Store and Cafe in South Kolkata was putting it into its salads at the time.
Is Kolkata's Parsi cheese the same as Mumbai's topli na paneer?
It shares the name and the basket. Rita Jamshed Kapadia, writing on ParsiCuisine.com, explains that topli means basket in Gujarati, and cookbook author Niloufer Mavalvala notes the ring marks the wicker leaves on each piece. Mavalvala calls it a Mumbai speciality served at wedding and navjote feasts, and a Food52 piece on Mumbai's makers also describes it at the start of Parsi wedding meals. Bhicoo Manekshaw traced its origin to Surat, according to a 2014 DNA report. Food52 also points to Surat, where Bohri hawkers once sold it in the neighbourhoods.
The older recipes set the milk with rennet. Niloufer Ichaporia King, quoted by DNA, describes rennet made from dried chicken gizzard, and Food52 names calf intestines or chicken gizzards as the traditional choice. Food52 adds that most Parsi home caterers now use vegetarian rennet. The 2018 Kolkata profile does not say which rennet Batliwala used, so we cannot tell you. For how the cheese is made at home and where it is found in Mumbai, read our main guide to Topli na paneer.
Is Bandel cheese Parsi?
No. Bandel is a different Bengal cheese with a different history. The online magazine Homegrown, in a 2021 article by Pankhuri Shukla, says Bandel cheese takes its name from the town of Bandel in West Bengal and owes its existence to the Portuguese who settled there.

The two cheeses part ways at nearly every stage. Here is how the sources describe them:
| Topli na paneer (Kolkata, 2018) | Bandel cheese (Homegrown, 2021) | |
|---|---|---|
| Community | Parsi | Portuguese settlers in Bengal |
| Milk | Buffalo milk (Batliwala) | Cow's milk |
| How it sets | Milk set in small cane baskets (published Parsi recipes use rennet) | Acid such as lemon juice, then moulded |
| Shape and finish | Soft, basket-marked pieces | Flat discs, smoked (brown) or plain (cream) |
| Where sold | Ripon Street, by appointment (2018) | Kolkata's New Market |
Homegrown sent Bandel buyers to Old J Johnson in New Market and compared its texture to feta. Topli na paneer is much softer: Mavalvala says a piece is soft enough to fall apart, and Food52 and Kapadia both describe it kept in its own salty whey.
Can you still buy topli paneer in Kolkata today?
We don't know, and we would rather say so than guess. The last published detail we could verify is India Today's March 2018 line: Ripon Street, by appointment only. Batliwala was 73 then and had already cut back to two products. No newspaper or magazine page we could open since then confirms she is still making it, or that anyone else in Kolkata has started.

For a sense of the community the cheese belongs to, our page on the Parsis of Kolkata covers its history in the city. If no one has carried the recipe on, topli na paneer can be made in a home kitchen with rennet and small baskets, and the method is in our topli na paneer guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is there Parsi cheese in Kolkata?
Yes, at least as recently as 2018. Kolkata's Parsi cheese is topli na paneer, a soft cheese set in small cane baskets. India Today reported in March 2018 that Viloo Batliwala was the only person in the city making it, selling from Ripon Street by appointment, with fresh batches on Tuesdays and Fridays.
Who makes topli na paneer in Kolkata?
The only maker named in print is Viloo Batliwala. India Today's 2018 profile said she had made it for over 40 years, learnt the recipe from her mother-in-law and used fresh buffalo milk set in cane baskets. We found no later report confirming she still makes it or naming a successor.
Is Bandel cheese Parsi?
No. Homegrown says Bandel cheese is named after the town of Bandel in West Bengal and credits it to the Portuguese who settled there. It is a salty, flat disc of cheese sold smoked or plain in Kolkata's New Market. The Parsi cheese of Kolkata is topli na paneer, a different cheese entirely.
Where can you buy topli paneer in Kolkata?
The last verified source is India Today in March 2018, which listed Viloo Batliwala on Ripon Street, by appointment only, at Rs 260 for eight pieces. We could not confirm any Kolkata seller after 2018, so treat that detail as historical rather than current.
What is the difference between Bandel cheese and topli paneer?
Topli paneer is Parsi, set with rennet in published recipes, drained in small cane or wicker baskets and kept soft in its own whey. Homegrown describes Bandel as Portuguese in origin, made from cow's milk curdled with an acid such as lemon juice, pressed into flat discs and sold smoked or plain, with a feta-like texture.
PalV's Kasti


