On this page
- What does the Vendidad say about where the dead should be laid?
- Why does scripture ordain exposure? The Druj Nasu and pollution
- What does the Vendidad say about burial by comparison?
- Is the dakhma itself considered pure?
- Is dokhmenashini older than Zarathushtra, or a later rule?
- How do Parsis read this command today?
- Frequently asked questions
Dokhmenashini, the laying of the body in a dakhma to be exposed to birds and sun, is ordained in the Vendidad, one of the books of the Avesta. Fargard 6 tells the faithful to lay the dead "on the highest summits", where corpse-eating dogs and birds are always found, and Fargard 8 says that when someone dies, "they shall search for a Dakhma". The reason the text gives is pollution. In Fargard 7 the demon of decay, the Druj Nasu, rushes upon the body as soon as the soul leaves it. Mary Boyce of Encyclopaedia Iranica and Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia both describe the aim as disposing of the body with the least harm to the good creations, among them earth, water and fire. Priest-scholars such as J.J. Modi and Karanjia read the rule this way. Historians add that exposure became general in Iran only slowly.
For what a dakhma is and how Mumbai's Doongerwadi works today, start with our guide to the Tower of Silence. This page stays with the scriptural reasons.
શહેરેવર રોજ
Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.
What does the Vendidad say about where the dead should be laid?
The key passage is Vendidad 6.44 to 6.51, in James Darmesteter's translation for the Sacred Books of the East. Zarathushtra asks where the bodies of the dead should be taken. Ahura Mazda answers that they go to the highest summits, where corpse-eating dogs and birds are known to be. The body is to be fastened by the feet and the hair with iron, stone or clay, so that dogs and birds cannot carry the bones "to the water and to the trees". Once the bones are bare, they go into a receptacle out of reach of dog, fox and wolf, where rain-water cannot stay. A family that cannot afford such a receptacle may lay the dead out in the open, "clothed with the light of heaven, and beholding the sun".
Vendidad 8.2 adds the instruction to seek a dakhma. The nineteenth-century catechism of Erachji Sohrabji Meherjirana, translated and edited by Dastur Firoze Kotwal and James Boyd in 1982, quotes both verses: the body is to be placed on a high place, and for the departed one should "seek a high dakhma". Kotwal and Boyd note that the word dakhma seems originally to have meant a grave, and that in this passage it is a technical term.
Karanjia, writing in Jame Jamshed in May 2017, sums up the religious texts as four requirements. The remains go to an elevated place, as far from habitation as possible. They are exposed to corpse-eating birds such as vultures, kites and crows. And they are exposed to the rays of the sun, which he calls khurshed nagirashni.
Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
Why does scripture ordain exposure? The Druj Nasu and pollution
The Vendidad's answer is the Druj Nasu, the demon of dead matter. In Fargard 7, Ahura Mazda says that the Druj Nasu rushes upon the dead the moment the soul has gone, coming from the north as a raging fly. She stays on the body until a dog has seen it or the flesh-eating birds have flown towards it. Erachji's catechism links this verse to the sagdid, the dog's gaze. Citing the Pahlavi commentary on Fargard 7, it says that if a vulture, crow or other corpse-eating bird sees the body or flies over it, that counts as sagdid.
Mary Boyce, writing in Encyclopaedia Iranica in 1993, explains why the stakes were so high. The body of a righteous believer was held to be the worst source of pollution in the world, because such a death was a victory for evil. The aim of exposure, she writes, was to be rid of the decaying flesh with as little harm as possible to the good creations. Erachji's catechism puts it in ritual terms: the druj i nasush putrefy the body and attack the living, and the priests' chanting of the Gathas at the house, the gehsarnu, keeps them away.
J.J. Modi, in a paper read to the Anthropological Society of Bombay on 30 September 1891, put the principle in one line. The rites rest on respect for the dead and on disposing of the body, once the soul has left it, in the way least harmful to the living. The catechism gives a similar reason for choosing a height: the foul air from the body rises into the sky instead of reaching people.
Karanjia, in a separate Jame Jamshed column of July 2017, lists four teachings behind dokhmenashini. The first is the least possible harm to earth, water and air. Next comes letting the body return to the elements as soon as possible. He adds never polluting fire with dead matter, and the timely release of the soul and its non-physical parts. Whether these hold up as hygiene today is a separate question, which we look at in Dokhmenashini and modern science.
Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
What does the Vendidad say about burial by comparison?
The same Fargard measures how long the ground stays unclean. Vendidad 7.46 says that ground on which the dead lay in the sun for a year is clean again. Vendidad 7.48 says that earth in which a body was buried is clean again only after fifty years. Vendidad 3.36 to 3.39 sets penalties for a burial not undone within half a year and within a year, and calls one left into the second year a trespass with no atonement. Darmesteter's note to Vendidad 6.51 adds that the dead must see the sun, which is why the bone receptacle has holes to let the light in.
Is the dakhma itself considered pure?
No. Vendidad 3.9 names the place where most dakhmas stand as one of the places where the Earth feels sorest grief. Vendidad 7.50 says the ground under a dakhma is not clean until the dust of the body has mingled with the dust of the earth, and goes on to urge every one in the material world to pull dakhmas down. Darmesteter's note explains the logic. The law requires dakhmas, yet the dakhma is as unclean as any spot on earth, because the impurity that would otherwise be scattered is gathered in one place. In the same note he writes that dakhmas ought to be pulled down every fifty years so their sites can recover. How a modern dakhma is built and consecrated is covered in Dakhma construction and consecration.
Is dokhmenashini older than Zarathushtra, or a later rule?
Here the priestly and the academic accounts differ, and we give both. Karanjia writes that the Mazdayasnis used this system even before the prophet Zarathushtra, that Zarathushtra accepted it and strengthened it, and that kings in the Shahnameh ask to be laid in dakhmas.
James Darmesteter, in the introduction to his Vendidad translation (second edition, 1895), reads the history differently. He writes that in Persia the burning of the dead had long been forbidden while burial "was still general", and that the priestly rules became the general law only later, with the rise of the Magian religion. Mary Boyce, in Encyclopaedia Iranica, says there is no trace of exposure among the western Iranians before Zoroastrianism, which took it up slowly as the faith spread. Both cite the Greek historian Herodotus. He passed on, as a report he could not confirm, that a Persian's body was not buried until a bird or dog had torn it. The Magians, he added, did this openly, while the Persians covered the body with wax and buried it.
How do Parsis read this command today?
For orthodox teachers the command stands. Karanjia calls dokhmenashini "the most ecological and nature friendly way" of disposal, and says it matters spiritually as well, so that the body's spiritual parts rejoin air and sunlight. Others in the community argue that the system has stopped working. Jehangir Patel, editor of Parsiana, told Outlook in a report by Manu Joseph (dated 5 February 2022 on Outlook's website) that "the system of Dakhma is not working" and that the community has to look at alternatives. Khojeste Mistree, quoted in the same report, said that the scriptures do not say only vultures should consume the body. On the birds' role and their decline, see Vultures and the Tower of Silence.
Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
Frequently asked questions
Which scripture ordains dokhmenashini?
The Vendidad, one of the books of the Avesta. Fargard 6, verses 44 to 51, tells the faithful to lay the dead on the highest summits where corpse-eating dogs and birds are found, and Fargard 8, verse 2, says to search for a dakhma. Erachji's catechism, edited by Kotwal and Boyd, cites both verses.
What is the Druj Nasu?
In the Vendidad, the Druj Nasu is the demon of dead matter. Fargard 7 says it falls on the body as soon as the soul leaves, in the shape of a fly, and stays until a dog sees the body or birds fly towards it. Keeping its pollution from the living is the reason given for exposure.
Why must the body be exposed to the sun?
Vendidad 6.51 describes the remains as "clothed with the light of heaven, and beholding the sun", and Darmesteter's note on that verse says the dead must see the sun. Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia lists exposure to the sun's rays, khurshed nagirashni, as one of four requirements he draws from the religious texts.
Does the Vendidad say the dakhma is holy ground?
No. Vendidad 3.9 counts the place where dakhmas stand among those where the Earth feels sorest grief, and Vendidad 7.50 says that ground stays unclean until the dust of the dead mingles with the earth, then urges people to pull dakhmas down. Darmesteter explains that the dakhma gathers impurity into one spot.
Did ancient Iranians always expose their dead?
Accounts differ. Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia writes that the system was in use even before Zarathushtra. Darmesteter wrote that burial was still general in Persia before Magian rules became law, and Mary Boyce, in Encyclopaedia Iranica, says Zoroastrianism adopted exposure slowly as it spread among the western Iranians.
PalV's Kasti


