Skip to content

Life events

Why Don't Parsis Burn or Bury Their Dead? Is There a Zoroastrian Burial Ground?

What the Avesta says about fire and earth, what ancient Persians did, and where the cremation debate stands.

Title card: Why Parsis don't burn or bury their dead – What the Vendidad says about fire, earth and water, and where the crem
On this page
  1. What does the Avesta say about burning the dead?
  2. Why is burial forbidden for Zoroastrians?
  3. Why do fire, earth and water matter so much?
  4. Did the ancient Persians ever bury their dead?
  5. Is cremation allowed for Parsis today?
  6. Is there a Parsi or Zoroastrian burial ground?
  7. Frequently asked questions

Parsis don't burn or bury their dead because the Zoroastrian scriptures treat the dead body as the greatest source of pollution in the world, and hold fire, earth and water to be sacred. Burning would put dead matter into fire. Burying would put it into the earth, and from there into water. James Darmesteter, the Vendidad's 19th-century translator, reads the scripture as treating both acts as sins for which there is no atonement. So the body is instead laid out on high ground in a dakhma, the Tower of Silence, to be exposed to the sun and to birds. This method is called dokhmenashini. That is the classical answer. Today some Parsis choose cremation, and that choice is still debated, as we explain below. Traditional Parsi funeral grounds in India hold dakhmas, not graves.

TodayTue 17 Nov

શહેરેવર રોજ

Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What does the Avesta say about burning the dead?

James Darmesteter, who translated the Vendidad for the Sacred Books of the East in 1880, put the core point plainly in his introduction: the older Indo-European peoples either burnt or buried their dead, and the Avesta holds both customs to be sacrilegious. For fire, he explains, no death and no uncleanness may be allowed to enter it, since it is the purest part of the good creation. He calls burning the dead the most heinous of sins.

The verse he points to is in the first chapter of the Vendidad (1.16 in the avesta.org numbering), where Angra Mainyu creates an unatonable sin that Darmesteter translates as "the cooking of corpses". There is a translation wrinkle here. Darmesteter's own footnote to that verse reads it as cooking a corpse and eating it, while his introduction cites the same verse for burning the dead. Both readings appear in his work.

Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia, writing in Jame Jamshed in July 2017, lists among the reasons for dokhmenashini that fire must not be polluted in any way by nasa, the dead matter of a human body, because fire is sacred and has a special place in the religion.

Why is burial forbidden for Zoroastrians?

The earth is protected in the same way. In Vendidad 3.8 the second place where the earth feels the sorest grief is the place where the most corpses of dogs and men lie buried. Vendidad 3.36 to 3.39 sets penalties for a man who buries a body and fails to dig it up within half a year, then within a year, and calls the failure to dig it up within the second year a trespass with no atonement. Vendidad 7.47 to 7.48 says ground where a body has been buried becomes clean again only after fifty years.

Darmesteter sums it up: burying the dead is, like burning them, a deed with no atonement. A 19th-century priestly catechism by Erachji Meherjirana, translated with commentary by Dastur Firoze Kotwal and James Boyd in 1982, adds a practical rule: the dakhma must be built so that the fluids of the body do not enter the ground, because that would make nearby wells and streams impure. J.J. Modi, in The Religious Ceremonies and Customs of the Parsees (1922), quotes a Bombay description stating that the religion strictly forbids the dead from being buried, burnt or thrown into seas and rivers, so that earth, fire and water are not polluted.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Why do fire, earth and water matter so much?

Mary Boyce, writing in Encyclopaedia Iranica in 1993, writes that a righteous believer's dead body counted as "the greatest source of pollution in the world", and that such a death was seen as a triumph for evil. Kotwal and Boyd describe the dead body, with its demons of pollution, as the greatest danger of contamination for the living. Both sources tie this to the same aim of keeping that pollution away from fire, earth and water.

Karanjia's 2017 column names four aims of dokhmenashini: harming earth, water and air as little as possible; letting the body return to the basic elements as soon as possible; keeping nasa away from fire; and releasing the soul on time. He also gives a spiritual reason, in his own view: that only dokhmenashini sends the semi-spiritual parts of a person back to their sources, and that other modes of disposal slow the progress of the soul. He argues, too, that cremation does not really return the body to the elements fast, because much of it becomes fine particles that take a long time to merge back into nature.

The same reasoning was offered to outsiders long ago. Dosabhai Framji Karaka's History of the Parsis (1884) records the reply given by Nasarvanji Beramji, Secretary to the Parsi Panchayet, to the Oxford Sanskrit professor Monier Williams on Malabar Hill. Zoroaster, Beramji said, taught that earth, fire and water must never be "defiled by contact with putrefying flesh". Karaka himself wrote in the same book that cremation was doubtless the best of existing methods, but sinful under Zoroaster's law because it pollutes fire. The question was already being asked in the 1880s.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Did the ancient Persians ever bury their dead?

Yes, some did. The Greek historian Herodotus says the Persians covered the body with wax and then buried it, while the Magi, the priestly tribe, exposed their dead openly. The geographer Strabo says much the same: the Persians smeared bodies with wax before burial, but the Magi were not buried and birds were allowed to devour them. Darmesteter reads this as a sign that burial stayed common among Persians for some time, and that the priestly rule became the general law later, as the Magian religion grew stronger. How exposure spread across Iran, and where it survives, is the subject of our post on Zoroastrian sky burial.

Is cremation allowed for Parsis today?

This is where the community disagrees, and we set out each side in its own words.

The orthodox position. Coomi Kapoor's history of the Parsis, excerpted in Scroll in July 2021, records that high priest Dastur Firoze Kotwal described accepting cremation as "a strike at the very foundation of our religion". Boyce wrote in Encyclopaedia Iranica that in Bombay, orthodox priests will not perform funeral rites if the body is cremated. Open magazine reported in July 2016 that orthodox Parsis see cremation as desecrating fire, which is holy, and see burial as polluting the earth.

The reformist position. Scroll reported in April 2016 that conditions at Doongerwadi had pushed some progressive Parsis towards cremation. Dinshaw Tamboly, a former trustee of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet and a leading advocate of cremation, told Open in July 2016 that the birds now at the towers "just peck" and that bodies lie there for days, even months. He helped set up a Zoroastrian prayer hall at the Worli crematorium. Scroll reported in April 2016 that the hall was inaugurated in August 2015 and held its first funeral in September 2015. Reformist priest Khushroo Madon told Scroll that some still see cremation as a defilement of fire, but that the hall "is fulfilling a definite need in the community". Scroll also reported then that the Punchayet did not allow families choosing cremation or burial to use the Doongerwadi prayer halls for the four days of funeral prayers.

Outside India the picture is different. Boyce notes that Zoroastrians abroad generally use ordinary undertakers and public crematoriums, with the prayers said at home or at the community's place of worship. The vulture question in Mumbai has its own post, Vultures and the Tower of Silence.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Is there a Parsi or Zoroastrian burial ground?

In India, the traditional Parsi funeral ground is a dakhma site, such as Doongerwadi in Mumbai, not a burial ground. Bodies there are not buried. Families in Mumbai who choose burial or cremation, Scroll reported in 2016, have had to use civic burial grounds and crematoriums rather than ones specific to the community.

Iran is different. Boyce records that the Tehran dakhma was replaced in 1937 by a cemetery called ārāmgāh, "place of rest", and that Kerman and Yazd followed in 1939 and 1960. In London, she notes, the community has its own chapel at Brookwood cemetery. How the towers of Iran compare with those in India is covered in Dakhmas of Iran vs India.

Frequently asked questions

Why don't Parsis burn or bury their dead?

Zoroastrian scripture treats the dead body as a powerful source of pollution and holds fire, earth and water sacred. Its translator James Darmesteter reads the Vendidad as treating both burning and burying the dead as sins with no atonement. The Vendidad instead has the body laid on high ground for the sun and birds.

Is cremation allowed for Parsis?

It is contested. Orthodox priests, including Dastur Firoze Kotwal, hold that cremation defiles sacred fire, and Encyclopaedia Iranica notes that orthodox Bombay priests will not perform funeral rites for the cremated. Reformist Parsis opened a prayer hall at the Worli crematorium in 2015, where reformist priests conduct the prayers. Ask your family priest.

Is there a Zoroastrian burial ground in India?

Traditional Parsi funeral grounds in India, such as Doongerwadi in Mumbai, hold dakhmas, and bodies there are not buried. Scroll reported in 2016 that Mumbai families choosing burial or cremation used civic burial grounds and crematoriums. In Iran, Zoroastrian cemeteries called ārāmgāh replaced the towers from 1937 onwards.

Did ancient Persians bury their dead?

Many did. Herodotus and Strabo both describe Persians coating the body in wax and burying it, while the Magi, the priestly tribe, left their dead to be eaten by birds. The scholar James Darmesteter read this as evidence that the priestly rule of exposure only later became the general law of Zoroastrians.

What does the Vendidad say about burying a body?

Vendidad 3.36 to 3.39 sets penalties for anyone who buries a human or dog body and does not dig it up within half a year or a year, and calls not digging it up within the second year a sin with no atonement. Vendidad 7.48 says buried ground becomes clean only after fifty years.

Share this article

Facebook