Skip to content

Life events

Dokhmenashini vs Cremation: How the Two Compare for Parsis

What each side says about faith, the environment and the practical side of a Parsi funeral in Mumbai.

Title card: Dokhmenashini vs cremation – Faith, environment and practice: how the two Parsi funeral choices compare, side by
On this page
  1. What is the difference between dokhmenashini and cremation?
  2. What does the Zoroastrian faith teach about cremation?
  3. Which is better for the environment, dokhmenashini or cremation?
  4. How do the two compare in practice?
  5. Will a priest pray for a Parsi who is cremated?
  6. How many Parsis choose cremation over dokhmenashini?
  7. Frequently asked questions

Dokhmenashini and cremation differ on all three counts. Religiously, traditional priests and scholars teach that dokhmenashini is the prescribed Zoroastrian method and that burning the body defiles fire, while reformist priests perform the prayers for Parsis who are cremated. Environmentally, the traditional side describes exposure to the sun and birds as the method that harms the elements least, while reformists in Mumbai point to the loss of the vultures, which they say has left the dakhmas unable to work as intended. Practically, the main differences are where the four days of prayers can be held, who may attend, and whether the family can stay with the body. We set out each side below in its own words, without taking a side.

TodayTue 17 Nov

શહેરેવર રોજ

Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What is the difference between dokhmenashini and cremation?

Dokhmenashini means laying the body of the deceased in a dakhma (also spelt dokhma), a raised circular stone structure open to the sky, where the sun and birds of prey do the work of disposal. In Mumbai this happens at Doongerwadi on Malabar Hill. How a dakhma is built and used is explained in our guide to the Tower of Silence.

Cremation, for Parsis in Mumbai, usually means the electric crematorium at Worli, with prayers held in the hall the Prayer Hall Trust built there. The Free Press Journal reported in 2022 that the funeral rituals are performed according to Zoroastrian procedure before the body goes into the electric machine. The practical steps for arranging one are covered in our page on Parsi cremation.

What does the Zoroastrian faith teach about cremation?

The traditional teaching

Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia, in his published questions and answers on death, writes that dokhmenashini rests on four principles: disposal away from where people live, on raised ground, under the rays of the sun, and open to birds of prey. He gives the religious reasons as doing the least harm to earth, water and air, keeping dead matter away from fire, which is sacred, and the timely release of the soul. In his account, any other mode of disposal, chosen or forced, slows the soul's progress.

The orthodox scholar Khojeste Mistree put the same position to AFP in June 2016. He said burning the body desecrates fire, burying it pollutes the earth and putting it in water sullies the water, and that from a religious point of view cremation is "clearly" wrong, although those who want it can choose it. Mary Boyce, writing in the Encyclopaedia Iranica in 1993, recorded that in Bombay orthopractic priests do not perform the funeral rites when the body is cremated.

The reformist view

Reformist priests do not accept that the prayers must be withheld. Khushroo Madon, one of the first two priests to serve at the Worli hall, told Scroll in April 2016 that some Parsis still see cremation as a defilement of fire, but that the hall was meeting a real need in the community and he expected most families to move to cremation. Boyce also notes that Parsi reformers pressed from the mid-19th century for changes, some of them for burial in place of exposure, and that small, scattered Zoroastrian communities had long buried their dead out of necessity. In the Gujarat High Court in July 2021, Senior Advocate Percy Kavina said, as reported by Parsi Times, that Parsis in many places had been burying their dead for seven or eight decades and that burial was not sacrilegious.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.

Which is better for the environment, dokhmenashini or cremation?

We found no published study that measures the two side by side, so here is what each side says. Karanjia argues that every other mode of disposal uses up natural resources and pollutes one element or another. He adds that cremation does not truly dispose of the body in a few hours, because much of it becomes fine particles that end up in the scrubber, the chimney or the air. Open magazine reported in July 2016 that orthodox Parsis regard the fumes from cremation as toxic, and see the vultures, followed by drying the bones in the sun, as purifying the dead while keeping fire, air and water clean.

Reformists make a different argument: without vultures, the dakhmas no longer work as intended. Dinshaw Tamboly, a former Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) trustee, told AFP in 2016 that kites and crows only pecked at the bodies, which lay for six to eight months, and that the pallbearers had complained of the smell. Mistree disputed this in the same report, saying the dakhmas still "work effectively, although slightly slower". Karanjia's view is that only the birds-of-prey principle has weakened, and the other three still hold. Why the birds disappeared is the subject of our post on Vultures and the Tower of Silence.

How do the two compare in practice?

QuestionDoongerwadi (dokhmenashini)Worli prayer hall (cremation)
Four days of prayersIn the bunglis (prayer halls), with boarding for the four days for Parsi and Irani Zoroastrians, per the BPPIn the Worli hall, which seats 200 and is open to all communities, with Parsi Zoroastrians given first priority (Scroll, 2016)
Non-Parsi relativesThe BPP says non-Parsis may not see the body after the Sachkar ritualMay attend the rites in the hall (Open, 2016)
Family and the bodyNo family member goes inside the dakhma (Open, 2016)Family can stay with the body until the end (Open, 2016)

The prayers themselves are much the same. Open reported in 2016 that the rituals for a cremated Parsi are similar to those at Doongerwadi, and that the main difference is that relatives, especially non-Parsi ones, may attend. Jehangir Patel, editor of Parsiana, told the Free Press Journal in January 2024 that non-Parsis at Worli are not seated apart, as they are at Doongerwadi, and called the hall "a real blessing" for families who wanted an alternative.

Close-up of white tuberose flowers with pink-tipped buds
Tuberose flowers in bloom. Photo: Swaminathan from Gurgaon, India, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Will a priest pray for a Parsi who is cremated?

Some will and some will not. The BPP does not let families who choose cremation or burial use the Doongerwadi prayer halls for the four-day rites, Scroll reported in 2016, and in October 2024 the Free Press Journal reported that the Tower of Silence management had barred families who opted for cremation from its prayer halls. Tamboly told Open in February 2014 that the high priests had called cremation sacrilegious, and the magazine reported that the high priests had forbidden cremation and burial and described those who chose or advocated them as "renegades".

In 2009 the BPP barred two reformist priests, Framroze Mirza and Khushroo Madon, from Doongerwadi and two Agiaries; among the reasons the trustees gave was that they prayed for Parsis who had been cremated. On 11 March 2011 a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court, in Jamsheed Kanga & Anr v Parsi Panchayat Funds & Properties (Appeal No. 256 of 2010), held that under the 1884 Deed of Trust the trustees could not prevent any duly ordained Parsi Zoroastrian priest from performing rites at Doongerwadi and the two Agiaries. The BPP appealed, and on 27 April 2015 the Supreme Court accepted a mediated settlement, which Scroll reported allowed Mirza and Madon to perform funeral rites in those places only for their immediate family, after filing an affidavit with the BPP.

At Worli, Framroze Mirza is the priest in charge, assisted by two other priests, according to the Free Press Journal in January 2024. Tamboly told Scroll in 2016 that 11 more reformist priests had begun conducting funerals at the hall by then.

Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first. This is general information, not legal advice; for a specific case, speak to a lawyer.

How many Parsis choose cremation over dokhmenashini?

The figures come from people on different sides and differ. Before the Worli hall opened in August 2015, about 6% of Mumbai Parsi funerals were cremations, Patel told AFP in 2016, rising to about 15% after it opened; Scroll gave similar figures that year. Mistree told AFP the same year that a "massive majority" still favoured the traditional way. In January 2024 the Prayer Hall Trust put cremations at 15 to 20% of funerals, against an earlier 7 to 8%, and Tamboly, by then a member of the Trust, put them at 100 to 120 of an average 650 funerals a year. In April 2024 Patel said just over 10% of funerals were done in non-traditional ways.

Well-known Parsis have been cremated at Worli, among them Cyrus Mistry in September 2022, former BPP chairman Minoo Shroff in April 2024 and Ratan Tata in October 2024, the Free Press Journal reported. Jehangir Pandole, who died in the same car crash as Mistry, was taken to Doongerwadi because his family preferred the traditional custom. How the practice has shifted year by year is traced in Changes in dokhmenashini.

Frequently asked questions

Can a Parsi be cremated?

Yes. In Mumbai a minority of families choose it, usually at the Worli municipal crematorium, where the Prayer Hall Trust runs a hall for the funeral prayers; 2024 estimates range from just over 10% to 15–20% of funerals. Traditional voices such as Ervad Ramiyar Karanjia and Khojeste Mistree hold that cremation wrongs fire, so the choice remains contested.

Can the four-day prayers be held at Doongerwadi after a cremation?

Not as reported. Scroll said in 2016, and the Free Press Journal in October 2024, that families who choose cremation are barred from the Doongerwadi prayer halls for the four days of prayers. Dinshaw Tamboly told the Free Press Journal in April 2024 that this refusal left his group no choice but to set up the Worli hall.

Why do some Parsis now prefer cremation?

The main reason given is the loss of the vultures. Former BPP trustee Dinshaw Tamboly told AFP in 2016 that bodies were lying in the dakhmas for six to eight months. Open reported in July 2016 that cremation also lets the family stay with the body to the end and lets non-Parsi relatives attend the rites.

Do Parsis bury their dead anywhere?

Yes. Mary Boyce recorded in the Encyclopaedia Iranica that small, scattered Zoroastrian communities buried their dead out of necessity, and that some 19th-century Parsi reformers argued for burial. In July 2021, Parsi Times reported, Senior Advocate Percy Kavina told the Gujarat High Court that Parsis in many places had been burying their dead for seven or eight decades.

Share this article

Facebook