Skip to content

Food

Kharia ni jelly: the sweet Parsi trotter jelly, and what the record says

The sweet, sherry-scented sibling of kharia, and what the sources do and do not say about it.

Title card: Kharia ni jelly, explained – The sweet, sherry-scented trotter jelly beside kharia, and what the sources record
On this page
  1. What is kharia ni jelly?
  2. How is kharia ni jelly different from kharia (chora ma kharia)?
  3. Is kharia ni jelly a Parsi winter breakfast?
  4. Are trotter dishes still cooked in Parsi homes?
  5. Is there a reliable kharia ni jelly recipe?
  6. Frequently asked questions

Kharia ni jelly is the sweet member of the Parsi trotter family. Niloufer Ichaporia King, in her 2007 cookbook My Bombay Kitchen, describes it as a clear, sweet jelly made from trotters and flavoured with sherry, a dish her mother and many others adored. Its savoury sibling is kharia, trotters slow-cooked with black-eyed peas, and that stew is the one Niloufer Mavalvala's cookbook and the food writer Meher Mirza place in winter. On the "winter breakfast" idea, we have to be straight with you: we could not find a cookbook author, historian or newspaper that records kharia ni jelly as a breakfast dish, or ties the jelly itself to a season. That label turns up only in short web stories that credit no cook or cookbook.

TodayMon 16 Nov

અદીબેહેસત રોજ

Ardibehesht Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What is kharia ni jelly?

Kharia means trotters, the feet of goat or lamb, and it is also the name of the best-known Parsi dish made from them. Kharia ni jelly is the other dish King names from the same cut. In her description it has three defining features: it is clear, it is sweet, and it tastes of sherry.

King is honest that it divides families. She has loved kharia since childhood, yet she says she loathes the jelly, even though her own mother was devoted to it.

How is kharia ni jelly different from kharia (chora ma kharia)?

The two dishes start from the same ingredient and end up as opposites. Kharia, also called chora ma kharia, is a savoury, spiced stew of trotters and black-eyed peas. King calls it one of the great dishes of Parsi cuisine. Mirza, writing in The Juggernaut in 2022, remembers her mother's version as goat trotters left for hours in black-eyed peas until the pot turned into a thick, dark stew the colour of butterscotch.

Kharia ni jelly, by King's description, is clear and sweet rather than dark and spiced, and its defining flavour is sherry rather than masala.

Kharia (chora ma kharia)Kharia ni jelly
TasteSavoury and spicedSweet
LookThick, dark stewClear jelly
Key additionsBlack-eyed peas, aromatic spicesSherry
Season in the sourcesWinter (Mavalvala, Mirza)Not recorded

Mavalvala, in The Route to Parsi Cooking (2024), adds practical notes on kharia. Lamb trotters are fattier and meatier, she writes, while goat trotters are thinner and leaner. The stew can only be made in large batches, through a long, slow cook. She also records that many in the West cook it with pig trotters, because six decades ago, when Parsis from the subcontinent began moving there, those were the only trotters easy to buy.

Is kharia ni jelly a Parsi winter breakfast?

The winter part is documented for kharia, the stew. Mavalvala says outright that kharia is best eaten in the colder months, and Mirza recalls that winter was when her mother made chora ma khariya.

For the jelly, the record is thin. None of the cookbook writers or journalists we could read says when in the year it was made, or at which meal it was eaten. Two short web pieces from December 2022 call it a winter breakfast and list spices and spirits for it, but they name no cook, no family and no cookbook, so we have not repeated those details here. If your family ate kharia ni jelly in the morning, or only in winter, that is a memory worth writing down, because we could not find it written down anywhere.

Are trotter dishes still cooked in Parsi homes?

Trotter dishes belong to a wider Parsi taste for offal, and Mirza writes that this way of eating is slowly disappearing from Parsi homes. In her account, the recipes survived largely through cookbooks by home cooks, caterers and restaurateurs, among them Bhicoo Manekshaw, Jeroo Mehta and Katy Dalal. We have not been able to check whether any of those books carries a recipe for the sweet jelly.

Is there a reliable kharia ni jelly recipe?

Not one we could open and check. King and Mavalvala have both published recipes for kharia, the black-eyed pea stew, but we did not find a named cook's recipe for the sweet sherry jelly. Rather than stitch one together from unattributed web copy, we are leaving the method out. If an older relative in your family still makes it, we would be glad to hear from you.

For two more dishes from the Parsi kitchen, read our page on Vasanu and our guide to Doodh na puff.

Frequently asked questions

What is kharia ni jelly?

Kharia ni jelly is a Parsi dish of trotters set into a jelly. Cookbook author Niloufer Ichaporia King describes it as clear, sweet and flavoured with sherry. It is a separate dish from kharia, the savoury trotter stew with black-eyed peas, even though both begin with the same cut of meat.

How is kharia ni jelly different from chora ma kharia?

Chora ma kharia is a dark, spiced stew of trotters cooked for hours with black-eyed peas, and Mavalvala and Mirza both place it in winter. Kharia ni jelly uses trotters too, but King describes it as sweet, clear and flavoured with sherry. No source we read gives a season for the jelly.

Is kharia ni jelly sweet?

Yes. Niloufer Ichaporia King, writing in My Bombay Kitchen in 2007, describes the Parsi trotter jelly as sweet and flavoured with sherry. She adds that her mother and many others adored it, while she herself loathes it, so the dish has divided opinion even within a single Parsi family.

Is kharia ni jelly eaten for breakfast?

We could not confirm that. No cookbook, historian or newspaper we read says kharia ni jelly was a breakfast dish. The idea appears only in two short web pieces from December 2022 that credit no cook or cookbook. Families may well have eaten it in the morning, but we found no source that records it.

Why do Parsis eat kharia in winter?

Cookbook writer Niloufer Mavalvala says kharia, the trotter and black-eyed pea stew, is best eaten in the winter months, and food writer Meher Mirza remembers it as a winter dish in her Mumbai home. Neither gives a reason in the passages we read, and no source we found gives a season for the sweet trotter jelly.

Share this article

Facebook