On this page
Parsis began choosing the crematorium over the Tower of Silence mainly because the vultures that dokhmenashini relied on began vanishing from India in the 1990s, and the traditional process at Doongerwadi slowed badly. A second push came from prayers. The high priests would not allow prayers in the Doongerwadi bunglis for anyone who was to be cremated, so families who chose cremation had nowhere to pray. A prayer hall at the Worli municipal crematorium, opened in 2015, changed that. Families also give other reasons, reported in Open magazine and the Free Press Journal: at a cremation they can stay with the body to the end, non-Parsi relatives can attend the rites, and some intermarried Parsis cannot be laid at the Towers at all. Orthodox voices such as the scholar Khojeste Mistree hold that cremation desecrates fire. Both views are set out below.
અસપંદામેદ રોજ
Asfandarmad Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.
What happened to the vultures, and why did it matter?
Dokhmenashini, the laying of the body in a dakhma at the Tower of Silence, depended on vultures to do their work quickly. From the 1990s the vultures of the subcontinent crashed. A 2004 paper in Nature by J.L. Oaks and colleagues recorded a fall of more than 95% in the Oriental white-backed vulture, first noticed at Keoladeo National Park in India, and tied it to residues of the veterinary painkiller diclofenac. The birds took in the drug by feeding on treated livestock, and it caused kidney failure.
India's Drugs Controller General banned veterinary diclofenac in August 2006, according to a reply by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change published by PIB in December 2024. An AFP report from 2016 also dates the ban to 2006, and adds that by then the damage to Parsi sky burials had already been done.
At Doongerwadi, the Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) trustees brought in solar concentrators to dry the bodies faster, Mistree told NPR in 2012. But he added that they don't work in the monsoon, when clouds cover the sun. Open magazine wrote in 2014 that each adult body took at least about five days to dry in the solar wells. Dinshaw Tamboly, a former BPP trustee, told AFP in 2016 that kites and crows could not do the vultures' job.
Why were the prayers such a big reason?
For many families the harder question was where to pray. Tamboly told the Free Press Journal in April 2024 that the community's high priests had opposed cremation and kept the Doongerwadi halls closed to prayers for the cremated. Jehangir Patel, editor of Parsiana, told the same paper in January 2024 that this had been "a nightmare for families of those who opted for cremation."
Open reported in 2014 that one activist believed many Parsis would choose cremation but did not want to risk going without the final prayers. In his view, a hall open to the cremated would bring more people to cremation.
That hall opened in 2015 at the Worli municipal crematorium. Our guide to Parsi cremation explains how it began and how the rites there are done. A court ruling also bears on this. The BPP had barred two priests from Doongerwadi and two Agiaries, partly for praying for the cremated. On 11 March 2011 the Bombay High Court, in Jamsheed Kanga & Anr v Parsi Panchayat Funds and Properties & Ors (Appeal No. 256 of 2010), held that the ban was beyond the trustees' power and allowed the appeal.
What other reasons do families give for choosing cremation?
Staying with the body until the end
Open magazine noted in July 2016 that once the body is taken into the Towers of Silence for the last prayers, no family member is allowed inside, while a cremation lets the family stay with the body to the very end. Some Parsis cite that difference as part of their choice.
Non-Parsi mourners
The Free Press Journal noted in October 2024 that only Zoroastrians are allowed into the prayer halls of the cemetery. For families with non-Parsi in-laws, colleagues or friends, this matters. Open described the main difference at Worli as permission for the family, particularly its non-Parsi members, to attend the rites in the hall.
Intermarriage
Open's 2016 report called intermarriage another major reason: some Parsis who married outside the community cannot be laid at the Towers, so burial or cremation is their only route. The BPP's own Doongerwadi page says one dakhma there, the Modi Dokhma, is used for Parsi women married to non-Parsis who kept professing the religion until death and wished to be consigned to the Towers.
The Covid years
The priest in charge of religious services at the Worli hall told the Free Press Journal in January 2024 that cremations there rose during the Covid epidemic, when the bodies of those who died of the disease were not allowed into the Tower of Silence.
What do Parsis who oppose cremation say?
The orthodox case rests on the purity of the elements. In 2016 Mistree told AFP that the body cannot be burnt "because that's desecrating fire", cannot be buried because that pollutes the earth, and cannot be put in water. He said dokhmenashini still works "although slightly slower" without vultures, and that a "massive majority" still favour it. He accepted that those who want cremation can choose it, but added: "from a religious point of view clearly it's wrong."
In 2014, Open reported that the Zoroastrian high priests had strictly forbidden both cremation and burial, holding fire and earth to be sacred. Muncherji Cama, then a BPP trustee, told the magazine that the faith never placed its emphasis on the birds but on the sun, and that with solar panels the system was "working well enough."
Reformists answer from experience. One reformist told AFP in 2016 that things would be different if the vultures were still here, but that "now this is the best way to let the body pass." The separate argument over building a crematorium inside Doongerwadi itself is covered in our piece on the Doongerwadi crematorium debate.
Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
Frequently asked questions
Why do Parsis choose cremation?
The main reason reported is the loss of vultures, which slowed the traditional process at Doongerwadi. The prayer hall at the Worli crematorium, opened in 2015, also gave families of the cremated a place to pray. Open and the Free Press Journal report other reasons too: staying with the body to the end, non-Parsi mourners, and intermarriage.
Why did vultures disappear from India?
Vultures fed on livestock treated with diclofenac, a veterinary painkiller, and its residues caused kidney failure in the birds. A 2004 study in Nature linked the drug to a fall of over 95% in the Oriental white-backed vulture from the 1990s. India banned veterinary diclofenac in August 2006, according to the environment ministry.
Can intermarried Parsis use the Tower of Silence?
Not always. The Bombay Parsi Punchayet's website says its Modi Dokhma at Doongerwadi is used for Parsi women married to non-Parsis who kept professing the religion until death and wished to be consigned there. Open magazine reported in 2016 that some intermarried Parsis cannot be laid at the Towers, so they are buried or cremated.
Is cremation allowed in the Zoroastrian faith?
Views are divided. Open reported in 2014 that the high priests had forbidden cremation and burial because fire and earth are sacred, and orthodox scholar Khojeste Mistree called cremation religiously wrong. Reformists disagree, and since 2015 the Worli prayer hall has held prayers for the cremated. Ask your family priest about your own family's practice.
PalV's Kasti


