On this page
- What does "green funeral" mean today?
- Why do Parsis call dokhmenashini eco-friendly?
- How do its defenders compare it with cremation and burial?
- What has changed since the vultures disappeared?
- Is the Doongerwadi forest part of the green argument?
- Did Iran's Zoroastrians keep the practice?
- Frequently asked questions
Its defenders say it is, but that is an argument, not a measurement. Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia calls dokhmenashini, the Tower of Silence funeral, the most ecological way to dispose of the dead, the scholar Khojeste Mistree has called Zoroastrians "extremely eco-conscious", and a heritage sheet on the Mumbai municipal portal speaks of an "environmentally conscious approach". Their case is that no fuel is burnt, no resource is used up, and earth, fire and water are kept clean. We could not find any study that compares its footprint with cremation or burial. Since India's vultures began to vanish in the early 1990s, the process has also slowed, though by how much is disputed. Below, each view is set out in the words of the people who hold it.
શહેરેવર રોજ
Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.
What does "green funeral" mean today?
When AP reported in May 2019 that Washington had become the first US state to allow composting of human remains, called "natural organic reduction", it described green burial as the use of biodegradable shrouds or caskets without embalming. The Washington law took effect in May 2020. Its supporters argued that cremation releases carbon dioxide and particulates, and that conventional burial uses embalming chemicals and land.
Those are the same two methods Zoroastrian teaching has long refused, though for religious rather than climate reasons. That overlap is where the "original green funeral" idea comes from.
Why do Parsis call dokhmenashini eco-friendly?
The religious reasoning comes first. In his 1922 book on Parsi ceremonies, J.J. Modi reproduces a description of a Bombay tower by Nusserwanjee Byramjee, whom he calls the late secretary of the community's public charity funds. Byramjee wrote that the religion forbids burying, burning or putting the dead into rivers or the sea so that earth, fire and water are not polluted. He added that vultures did the work far faster than insects would in a grave.
Ervad Dr Ramiyar Karanjia puts the environmental claim plainly in his published Q&A on death and dokhmenashini. He calls it "the most ecological and nature friendly way" of disposing of the body, and "an economical as well as ecological method" that "does not use any resource from the ecosystem". Speaking to AFP in June 2016, the orthodox scholar Khojeste Mistree said Zoroastrians are "extremely eco-conscious" and that burning a body would mean "desecrating fire".
The view is not only the community's own. A heritage sheet on the Tower of Silence, published on the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai's portal for its Mumbai Legacy Project, says the practice "reflects an environmentally conscious approach" and refers to "the eco-friendly aspect" of Parsi funeral customs.
Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
What about the rainwater?
Byramjee's account in Modi's book also describes drains that carry rainwater from the central well to four underground wells with a thick layer of sand at the bottom, with charcoal and sandstone as filters, so the water is cleaned before it reaches the ground. How a dakhma is laid out is covered in our guide to the Tower of Silence.
How do its defenders compare it with cremation and burial?
Karanjia argues that cremation does not really dispose of a body within hours. In his words, burning turns much of it into "thousands of small suspended particles" that end up in the scrubber, the chimney or the air, and those take a long time to return to the natural elements. A buried body, he writes, "takes several years to disintegrate". By his account dokhmenashini, even in its present weakened form, takes a few weeks.
He also treats this as a spiritual question, not only a physical one. For him the method lets the spiritual parts of a person rejoin air and sunlight, and that is why he calls it the best option available to Zoroastrians today. Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
What has changed since the vultures disappeared?
The green case rests on fast, natural decomposition, and that depended on vultures. AFP reported in 2016 that India's vulture population began falling sharply in the early 1990s because of diclofenac, an anti-inflammatory drug used on cattle. Dinshaw Tamboly, a former Bombay Parsi Punchayet trustee, told AFP that kites and crows did little and that bodies "would lie rotting in the heat for six to eight months". Mistree, in the same report, said the towers still "work effectively, although slightly slower".
The anthropologist Anne Rademacher, writing for the Rachel Carson Center's Environment & Society Portal in 2019, says solar collectors were tried at Doongerwadi to stand in for the birds and that "the results were insufficient". Karanjia accepts that the birds-of-prey principle "has considerably weakened in the last about two decades" but holds that the sun, the height and the distance from homes still do their work. For the wider story of the birds, read our post on Vultures and the Tower of Silence. Plans to bring them back are covered in Vulture aviaries for Doongerwadi.
Is the Doongerwadi forest part of the green argument?
In Rademacher's account, yes. She describes Doongerwadi as a 54-acre closed-canopy forest in the middle of South Mumbai, and writes that its stewards invited her to help with a biodiversity assessment as the vultures vanished. They showed, in her account, that the forest absorbs carbon dioxide, reduces pollution and noise, and lets rainwater soak into the ground. She presents this as an effort to explain that the land is both sacred and ecological, and can serve both purposes only if it stays a standing forest.

Did Iran's Zoroastrians keep the practice?
Mostly not. Mary Boyce, writing in the Encyclopaedia Iranica, records that during the twentieth century Zoroastrians in Iran moved from dakhmas to cemeteries with cement-lined graves. When it happened, and what part the birds played there, is covered in Vultures and Iran's dakhmas.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Tower of Silence eco-friendly?
Its defenders say yes. Ervad Ramiyar Karanjia calls dokhmenashini the most ecological way to dispose of the dead because it uses no resource from the ecosystem, and a Mumbai municipal heritage sheet calls the practice environmentally conscious. No published study we found has measured its footprint against cremation or burial.
Why do Parsis not cremate or bury, if those are common elsewhere?
Zoroastrian teaching holds that a dead body must not pollute fire, earth or water, which is why burning, burial and disposal in water are refused. J.J. Modi recorded this reasoning in 1922, and Ervad Ramiyar Karanjia writes that the other methods pollute one element of nature or another. Practice varies between families and Agiaries; your family priest's guidance comes first.
How long does dokhmenashini take without vultures?
Accounts differ. Ervad Ramiyar Karanjia writes that in its present form it takes a few weeks. Former Bombay Parsi Punchayet trustee Dinshaw Tamboly told AFP in 2016 that bodies could lie for six to eight months. Khojeste Mistree told the same agency the towers still work, only more slowly than before.
Is a Parsi funeral the same as human composting?
No. Human composting, which Washington state allowed from May 2020, places a body with wood chips and straw in a temperature- and moisture-controlled vessel until it becomes soil. Dokhmenashini exposes the body on an open stone platform to the sun and to birds. Both avoid burning and burial, but they work very differently.
Does the dakhma protect the groundwater?
That was the stated intent of its design. A description of a Bombay tower in J.J. Modi's 1922 book says rainwater from the central well runs through drains into underground wells with sand, charcoal and sandstone filters before it enters the ground. We found no recent survey of how these filters are maintained today.
PalV's Kasti


