Skip to content

Food

Bhakra Recipe: How to Make Parsi Bhakras, the Fried Tea-Time Sweet

A named FEZANA recipe for the fried Parsi sweet, how other versions differ, and the toddy connection

Title card: Bhakra: the fried Parsi tea-time sweet – A named FEZANA recipe, how versions differ, and where toddy comes in
On this page
  1. What is a bhakra?
  2. How do you make bhakras at home?
  3. How do other bhakra recipes differ?
  4. Do bhakras use toddy (taari)?
  5. Where do bhakras fit in Parsi cooking?
  6. Frequently asked questions

A bhakra is a small, round Parsi sweet made from a dough of semolina, flour, sugar, eggs and yogurt or toddy, rested for some hours and then deep-fried until golden. FEZANA's 2012 community cookbook Eat, Live, Pray lists it simply as "Parsi donut". To make bhakras, you beat butter and sugar, add eggs, work in the flours and yogurt a cup at a time, flavour the dough with cardamom, nutmeg and nuts, leave it covered for about six hours, then roll it out, cut small rounds and fry them. The full method below follows one named recipe, and the sections after it explain how other bhakra recipes differ and where toddy comes in.

TodayMon 16 Nov

અદીબેહેસત રોજ

Ardibehesht Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What is a bhakra?

A bhakra is a fried Parsi tea-time sweet, cut from a thick rolled dough into small rounds. It carries no topping. Food writer Perzen Patel, who writes as the Bawi Bride, describes a bhakra as a dense doughnut without the toppings. The Express Tribune, introducing Gulnaz Mondegarian's recipe in December 2013, called them "desi doughnuts". Homegrown, writing about toddy in Parsi cooking, calls them fried Parsi cookies.

In the recipes we could read, the doughnut comparison comes from the frying, not the shape. None of them cuts a hole in the middle. The FEZANA recipe below cuts "small rounds", and the Tribune method uses a biscuit cutter.

How do you make bhakras at home?

This method follows Mehroo H. Kazak's recipe "Bhakra, Parsi donut", contributed from Canada to FEZANA's Eat, Live, Pray: A celebration of Zarathushti culture and cuisine (2012, page 71). The steps are rewritten in our own words. Her quantities make ten dozen small bhakras, so this is a large batch. Plan ahead: the dough needs about six hours to rest before frying.

Ingredients

  • 5 tbsp (75 g) butter, melted and left to cool
  • 1½ cups (300 g) sugar
  • 3 eggs
  • 2 cups (320 g) semolina (ravo)
  • 3 cups (330 g) all-purpose flour (maida)
  • 1 cup (120 g) whole wheat flour
  • 2 cups (500 g) plain yogurt
  • 1 tsp vanilla essence
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 4 cardamoms, peeled and the seeds crushed
  • ¼ tsp nutmeg powder
  • ½ cup (60 g) almonds and walnuts, crushed
  • 1 tsp caraway seeds, crushed
  • Oil for deep-frying

Method

  1. Beat the cooled butter with the sugar until light and fluffy.
  2. Beat in the eggs until the mixture is smooth.
  3. Add the whole wheat flour in cupfuls, alternating with the yogurt.
  4. Do the same with the all-purpose flour and the rest of the yogurt.
  5. Stir in the semolina thoroughly.
  6. Add the vanilla, crushed cardamom seeds, caraway, almonds and walnuts.
  7. Fold the batter gently, then fold in the baking powder. Kazak says not to use a beater at this stage.
  8. Dust the top lightly with all-purpose flour, tie a cloth over the bowl and set it aside for about six hours.
  9. Pinch off small balls, roll each out to roughly 1 cm (half an inch) thick and cut out small rounds.
  10. Deep-fry the rounds until they turn golden brown.

Two details in this recipe are easy to miss. The baking powder goes in last, folded rather than beaten. And the long, covered rest is part of the method, not an optional step.

How do other bhakra recipes differ?

The published bhakra recipes we could read differ quite a lot. Perzen Patel's version, posted on her Substack in October 2024, came from Zarina Cama and Benaifer Gazder Daruwalla through the Facebook group "Parsi Cuisine". Patel writes that she never thought of cooking them herself until then, having heard how tricky the recipe can be. Only her ingredient list is free to read. The method sits behind a paywall.

What goes inMehroo H. Kazak (FEZANA, 2012)Perzen Patel (Substack, 2024)
Flours2 cups semolina, 3 cups all-purpose, 1 cup whole wheat2 cups semolina, 1 cup wheat flour
Eggs34
Sugar1½ cups1½ cups
Fat5 tbsp butter2 tbsp ghee
Yogurt2 cups2 tbsp
Nuts½ cup crushed almonds and walnuts100 g ground almonds
SpiceCardamom, nutmeg, caraway, vanillaCardamom, nutmeg
Raising agent listedBaking powderNone in the ingredient list
Yield10 dozen½ kg

Gulnaz Mondegarian's recipe in the Express Tribune's Ms T section (December 2013) is shorter on detail. Its ingredient list did not display when we opened the page. The method is the same outline: mix everything, knead, rest the dough for at least two hours, roll it out, cut circles with a biscuit cutter and deep-fry them in hot oil.

Do bhakras use toddy (taari)?

Some do. Taari is fermented palm toddy, and Homegrown describes bhakras as fried Parsi cookies that often use a taari-and-flour batter. Homegrown's explanation is practical. According to the site, in the 1970s and 1980s taari reached Maharashtra kitchens from Gujarat's palm groves in glass bottles, and a little flour was stirred in to quieten the fermentation so the bottles would not burst on the way. That flour-and-toddy mix, it says, then found its way into batters.

A toddy tapper climbing high up the bare trunk of a palm tree against a grey sky
A toddy tapper climbing a palm to collect the sap that becomes toddy. Photo: Vasukrishnan57, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Shop-bought toddy bhakras have been on sale in Mumbai too. Writing for Outlook Traveller (page last updated in September 2018), Shabnam Minwalla listed Grub Corner in Fort as a counter selling "toddy-laced bhakras" alongside Parsi pickles. We have not checked whether it still does.

The Kazak recipe above uses yogurt and baking powder, with no toddy, and we have kept it that way. We did not find a full, named toddy bhakra recipe we could open and check, so we are not giving toddy quantities here.

Where do bhakras fit in Parsi cooking?

For Perzen Patel, bhakras are tea-time food. She calls them a hot favourite at tea-time in numerous Parsi households, the 4 pm break of chai with something sweet. She also remembers an elderly seller who brought bhakras to her door in Mumbai, and, when she was growing up in New Zealand, carrying up to seven or eight packets back from India in her suitcase.

A white cup of milky masala chai on a saucer on a striped table mat
A cup of masala chai, the drink bhakras are eaten with at tea time. Photo: Original uploader was Pratheepps at en.wikipedia, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Bhakras also turn up inside another Parsi sweet. The traditional malido recipe in FEZANA's Eat, Live, Pray, credited to the late Kumi R. Sorabji and contributed by Rusi Sorabji, begins by frying bhakras and crushing them to crumbs with a rolling pin. Those are plain bhakras, though: farina, whole grain wheat flour, rolled oats, salt and water, with no sugar or eggs in the dough. The same book gives a baked alternative for that first step.

For the wider family of dishes these sweets sit beside, start with our guide to Parsi recipes or the overview of Parsi food. If you would rather cook something savoury from the same series next, try khichri saas ni machhi or Parsi-style bombil.

Frequently asked questions

What is a bhakra in Parsi cuisine?

A bhakra is a small, round, deep-fried Parsi sweet made from a rested dough of semolina, flour, sugar and eggs, flavoured with cardamom and nutmeg in the recipes we read. FEZANA's 2012 cookbook Eat, Live, Pray calls it a "Parsi donut". It is a solid round with no topping, and Perzen Patel calls it a tea-time favourite.

Is a bhakra the same as a doughnut?

Not quite. Bhakras are fried like doughnuts, and FEZANA's cookbook calls them a "Parsi donut" while the Express Tribune calls them "desi doughnuts", but they are cut as small solid rounds, with no hole and no topping. Perzen Patel describes them as dense doughnuts minus the toppings, while Homegrown calls them fried Parsi cookies.

Do bhakras have toddy in them?

Some do and some don't. Homegrown says bhakras often use a batter of taari, fermented palm toddy, mixed with flour, and Outlook Traveller has reported toddy-laced bhakras on sale in Mumbai. Other published recipes, such as Mehroo H. Kazak's in FEZANA's Eat, Live, Pray, use yogurt and baking powder instead of toddy.

How long should bhakra dough rest?

It depends on the recipe. Mehroo H. Kazak's FEZANA recipe has you dust the dough with flour, cover the bowl with a tied cloth and leave it for about six hours. Gulnaz Mondegarian's recipe in the Express Tribune asks for at least two hours. Either way, plan the resting time before you start frying.

How are bhakras used in malido?

In the traditional malido recipe printed in FEZANA's Eat, Live, Pray, the first step is to make plain bhakras from farina, whole grain wheat flour, oats, salt and water. They are fried golden, cooled and crushed into crumbs with a rolling pin. The book also gives a baked version of the same step.

Share this article

Facebook