Skip to content

Food

Parsi Tea-Time Snacks: What Parsis Serve With Their Evening Choi

Bhakra, chaapat, popatji, batasa and the sandwiches: what goes on the plate beside a cup of Parsi choi.

Title card: Parsi tea-time snacks – Bhakra, chaapat, popatji, batasa and sandwiches: what Parsis serve beside evening choi
On this page
  1. What do Parsis eat with their evening tea?
  2. What is a bhakra?
  3. What are popatjis, karkarias and chaapat?
  4. Which cakes and pastries appear on a Parsi tea table?
  5. What is batasa, and which bakery biscuits go with choi?
  6. Which savoury snacks do Parsis serve at tea time?
  7. Do Parsi families still make tea-time snacks at home?
  8. Frequently asked questions

With their evening choi, Parsis serve one snack made at home, or a plate of bakery biscuits when there's no time to cook. The home-made favourites are bhakra (a deep-fried, slightly dense cookie), chaapat (flat sweet pancakes), karkaria (banana fritters), popatji, mawa cake, kumas and date and walnut cake. From the bakery come batasa, khari, nankhatai and wine biscuits. When guests are expected, sandwiches join the tray. The archaeologist and caterer Kurush Dalal, writing about his own family, puts the rule simply: choi was never drunk on its own, and even now a slice of buttered bread or a biscuit is the least you put beside it. For the tea itself and the ritual around it, see our guide to Parsi choi.

TodayTue 17 Nov

શહેરેવર રોજ

Shehrevar Roj, Tir Mah · 1396 Y.Z.

Open the Parsi calendar →

What do Parsis eat with their evening tea?

One thing, but plenty of it. The cookbook author Niloufer Mavalvala remembers tea in large family homes this way: not a table loaded with choices, but one snack in a big enough batch to keep everyone going until dinner, with a different speciality on different days.

Between them, Dalal and Mavalvala name these as the regular tea-time sweets:

  • bhakra (also spelt bhokra)
  • chaapat, the Parsi sweet pancake
  • karkaria or kerkaria, a banana fritter or a fried biscuit depending on whose kitchen you ask
  • popaljee, which Mavalvala lists among her family's treats
  • mawa cake (mava nu cake) and kumas
  • date and walnut cake, which Dalal's great-aunt in Lonavala baked at least once a week, often without the walnuts
  • ghaari, the stuffed pastry kept for special days

What is a bhakra?

A bhakra is a small round of sweet dough, deep-fried until golden, with a soft middle. Dalal calls it a soft cookie and says the dough in his family was fermented with palm toddy, then fried in bulk and kept in large aluminium tins. Mavalvala describes bhokras as crisp at the edge and soft in the centre, a deep-fried cake her aunt fried with the family at tea time. The food writer Perzen Patel compares it to a dense donut without the toppings and calls it a hot favourite at tea time in many homes.

Recipes differ on the leavening. The bhakra recipe by Mehroo H. Kazak in FEZANA's 2012 cookbook Eat, Live, Pray uses no toddy. Its batter of semolina, flour, eggs and plenty of yoghurt is raised with baking powder, spiced with cardamom, nutmeg and caraway, and rested for about six hours before being rolled half an inch thick and fried. FEZANA titles it simply "Parsi donut".

What are popatjis, karkarias and chaapat?

Popatji, which Mavalvala spells popaljee, appears in her list as soft little bun cakes cooked in a special pan.

In Dalal's family, bananas that had gone too ripe became karkarias, fritters flavoured with elchi-jaiphal, the Parsi sweet spice of ground cardamom and nutmeg with sugar. Mavalvala's list describes kerkaria as deep-fried biscuits, so the name covers more than one thing.

Chaapat (also chapat) are flat, gently sweet pancakes. FEZANA's cookbook calls them unique to Parsi cuisine and different from both French crepes and North American pancakes, and suggests serving them with strawberry jam, or with sugar and lemon juice. At Mavalvala's in-laws, chaapat were made with coconut milk and a pinch each of saffron and cardamom.

Which cakes and pastries appear on a Parsi tea table?

Mavalvala's list opens with mava nu cake, made with mava (milk solids). Kumas sits beside it: Mavalvala describes kumas as a cake of saffron, almonds and sour yoghurt. Her tea-time chapter in The Vegetarian Parsi also includes kera nu cake, a banana cake.

For special occasions there was ghaari. Dalal describes thick discs of dough filled with bananas cooked in ghee, dates cooked until sticky, or a sweet dal paste. Mavalvala writes of gharis with fillings of dates, mava or coconut, and remembers how particular her father was that the date version, khajoor ni ghori, be warmed just right before it reached him.

What is batasa, and which bakery biscuits go with choi?

Batasa is a buttery, slightly salty biscuit meant for dunking. The writer Farrukh Dhondy, in an Outlook essay, remembers his grandmother's batasa as savoury and dotted with jeera, kept in glazed china jars beside the bhakra. Mavalvala's father dunked them into his morning tea, and she shared the habit with him for years.

Round, crumbly nankhatai biscuits with cracked tops piled on a paper napkin
Nankhatai, a crumbly bakery biscuit. Photo: Samir Nar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

In her book The Art of Parsi Cooking, as retold by The Better India, Mavalvala gives an origin story. When the Dutch left Surat in the 1700s, their bakery passed to a local employee, Faramji Dotivala. Toddy-raised bread kept without going mouldy but turned hard, and local doctors began recommending it to patients. Dotivala baked small dried buns for them, and these became batasa, first from toddy, flour and water, later enriched with butter or ghee. The same article notes that Surat, Navsari and Pune each make their own claims on the biscuit's origin. FEZANA's cookbook tells a related story: Parsi cooks working for the Dutch in Surat learned to raise bread with toddy, which it treats as the start of Surat's Parsi bakeries. The accounts agree on the Dutch and the toddy and differ on the details.

The other bakery staples Dalal lists for the quarter plate are khari (baked puff pastry), nankhatai, wine biscuits and coconut macaroons. FEZANA says Surat's bakers based nankhatai on eggless Scottish shortbread and added cardamom, cashews, almonds and pistachios. Mavalvala's home-baked khatai is a semolina and almond biscuit.

Which savoury snacks do Parsis serve at tea time?

Sandwiches come first. Dalal says his mother's chicken, egg and chutney sandwiches were famous, and his Tea Journey piece carries the recipes: the chutney is coconut, coriander, mint, green chillies and lime, and the cheese sandwiches use butter and grated Amul cheese. Mavalvala adds a paper-thin slice of salted cucumber and tomato to her chutney sandwiches. Her list also has mutton sandwiches, chicken pattice and samosas.

Weather and season decide the rest. On heavy monsoon afternoons, Dalal writes, bhajias appeared. His mother also shallow-fried overripe Rajeli bananas from Vasai in ghee, in one-inch pieces, until the outside caramelised and the inside turned soft like custard. For larger occasions Parsis serve a full high tea, and FEZANA names children's birthdays, agarnis and sari-wearing ceremonies among them. How families hosted tea away from the city is the subject of our post on Parsi hill-station tea parties.

Do Parsi families still make tea-time snacks at home?

Less than they did. Dalal writes that city life and nuclear families have turned tea into a quick cup in the morning or after office, and the snacks now often come from Paris Bakery, PAC or RTI. Mavalvala worries the custom may fade in families that have moved to the West. Our Parsi chai recipe covers that part, and the café version is explained in our guide to Irani chai.

Frequently asked questions

What do Parsis eat with tea?

Parsis usually serve one home-made snack with choi, such as bhakra, chaapat, karkaria, mawa cake or date and walnut cake. Bakery batasa, khari or nankhatai fill in on busy days, and sandwiches appear when guests come. Kurush Dalal writes that choi is never drunk alone, so buttered bread is the minimum.

What is a bhakra?

A bhakra is a Parsi tea-time sweet: a small round of sweet dough, deep-fried until golden, crisp outside and soft inside. FEZANA's cookbook calls it a "Parsi donut" and uses semolina, flour, yoghurt, cardamom and nutmeg. Kurush Dalal's family fermented the dough with palm toddy and stored the bhakras in tins.

What is batasa?

Batasa is a buttery, slightly salty Parsi bakery biscuit, sometimes flecked with jeera and made for dunking in tea. Niloufer Mavalvala traces it to a Surat bakery left behind by the Dutch in the 1700s, where dried buns raised with toddy were first sold as easy food for the sick.

What are popatjis?

Popatjis are a Parsi tea-time sweet. The cookbook author Niloufer Mavalvala spells the name popaljee and describes them as soft little bun cakes cooked in a special pan. She lists them among the treats served at tea in her family's homes, alongside kumas, gharis, kerkaria and daar ni pori.

Share this article

Facebook